Top 10 Bulldogs

[LostDoggy]

Re: Top 10 Bulldogs

Would anyone like to organise a WOOF edition of the top ten players? It doesn't have to be top 10. It can be top 15, top 20, whatever.

A way it could work is the person organising it can be responsible for counting all the votes? This can be done by those willing to participate sending a PM to the vote counter with their top 10/15/20 current Bulldogs players.

The player you rank first will receive 20 points, the player you rank second will receive 19 votes, the player you rank third will receive 18 points, etc etc until the 20th ranked player receives one vote (this is if we are doing it for top 20).

I'm not sure how much interest there would be. It would be good to have at least ten involved, and someone willing to count all the points to assemble a final top 20.

[Bulldog4life]

Re: Top 10 Bulldogs

My list on how they finished up after the finals and Premiership.

1. The Bont

2. JJ

3 Picken

4. T Boyd

5. Macrae

6. Wood

7. Dahl

8. Libba

9. Hunter

10. Morris

MBoyd, should be in but I can't see who to take out. Stringer will be in top 10 next year, Caleb Daniel and Dickson also very close.

Wow an All Australian this year left out. We have a super strong list.

[Rocco Jones]

Re: Top 10 Bulldogs

Would anyone like to organise a WOOF edition of the top ten players? It doesn't have to be top 10. It can be top 15, top 20, whatever.

A way it could work is the person organising it can be responsible for counting all the votes? This can be done by those willing to participate sending a PM to the vote counter with their top 10/15/20 current Bulldogs players.

The player you rank first will receive 20 points, the player you rank second will receive 19 votes, the player you rank third will receive 18 points, etc etc until the 20th ranked player receives one vote (this is if we are doing it for top 20).

I'm not sure how much interest there would be. It would be good to have at least ten involved, and someone willing to count all the points to assemble a final top 20.

That would be good. Maybe have a ranking at middle and end of year?

I think it would need shared view. For example my top 10 is what I saw as out and out the best players rather than who is most valuable to us. I think Lachie Hunter is a better player than Tom Boyd at this stage (just) but it terms of value, Tom is ahead.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Top 10 Bulldogs

That would be good. Maybe have a ranking at middle and end of year?

I think it would need shared view. For example my top 10 is what I saw as out and out the best players rather than who is most valuable to us. I think Lachie Hunter is a better player than Tom Boyd at this stage (just) but it terms of value, Tom is ahead.

That's a very good point. We'd all have to be on the same page and rankings would need to be done utilising the same criteria.

[Twodogs]

Re: Top 10 Bulldogs

Roughead would be pretty high on a list of importance but not so much best players.