Effort! - Positive!!!

[jeemak]

Re: Effort! - Positive!!!

I'm most boyant about our midfield prospects over the next four years.

Libba
Sherman
Wallis
Griff
Dahl
Smith
Picken
DJ
Cooney
Higgins (strange one to mention maybe, though he's a midfielder playing forward due to needs, IMO he's a go to transition player, a bit like how centremen used to play)


Throughout the game I couldn't help but think how well placed we were to endure the loss of two excellent contributors to the midfield in Cross and Boyd. By the looks of things we've nailed that section of the ground so far, and if we can top it off with one or two genuinely skilled quick draftees, and see Tutt come along once he's back to fitness and realises some continuity then we'll be laughing.

It's a positive thread, so I'll leave the bookends out of the discussion for now! Though, all isn't lost in that respect, just for now.

[ledge]

Re: Effort! - Positive!!!

Libba, Wallis and Dahlhaus are exceptional for their age, they are what we will build around,they will, be the clean disposal players we are searching for, with Clay as the real hard nut I can see us flying as early as next year once we grasp the game plan of Macca.
I also believe we have a coach the players believe in which is of course important.

[SonofScray]

Re: Effort! - Positive!!!

Enjoyed the game, hated the result.

The 'animals' Mac promised showed up. It was a hot footy all night.

[The Underdog]

Re: Effort! - Positive!!!

I just think Collingwood were fresher and it showed down the stretch. I don't believe they're the same team they were, but they are still a good team and our side gutsed it out.
I hate honourable losses, but that's what the game was. Plenty of spirit shown, I hope we can carry it forward and build on it.

The Ch. 7 commentators couldn't stop mentioning Collingwood's 9 day break when they started slowly. Nobody brought up that we've had 2 x 6 day breaks with a trip to Canberra versus them being fresher off a 9 day break, when they finished over the top of us .
I was rapt with the effort but could see the game ending the way it did a fair way out. Thought the pressure we brought for most of it was brilliant and that the final scoreline flattered the Pies.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Effort! - Positive!!!

In before someone rants about "honourable losses", "spewing up" or "accepting mediocrity". The truth is we are young, inexperienced and have alot of holes in our list. But despite all that we took it right up to a slightly undermanned Collingwood and almost won. I'm happy with that

There are 3 new positive spin threads despite losing. Not sure why it's being painted as good.
Words like 'almost' and excuses like young/inexperienced are just as bad as ones you mentioned.

[F'scary]

Re: Effort! - Positive!!!

There are 3 new positive spin threads despite losing. Not sure why it's being painted as good.
Words like 'almost' and excuses like young/inexperienced are just as bad as ones you mentioned.

cheers Chops

Just the improvement in form was enough for me at this stage. No, I don't like being satisfied with honourable losses but they showed something last night that hasn't been there except for the Adelaide match in round 2.

[Bornadog]

Re: Effort! - Positive!!!

There are 3 new positive spin threads despite losing. Not sure why it's being painted as good.
Words like 'almost' and excuses like young/inexperienced are just as bad as ones you mentioned.

Collingwood were younger than we were last night.

[Remi Moses]

Re: Effort! - Positive!!!

We're happy with the effort but as pointed out by the coach it's not acceptable to lose.
Heard him on the ABC and he wasn't happy with fans clapping the players off. Very impressive interview,said some players had to be taught not to run forward of the ball.Reckon if you don't adopt "Team" as a player you're Gonski!

[Eastdog]

Re: Effort! - Positive!!!

Not an excuse when it is the truth... We have a fairly young and inexperienced team and our list/team is full of holes and we did take it up to the Pies. Good effort but bad result I can take that rather than bad effort and good result like the previous two weeks.

I think we have players in our team that are nearing the ends of their careers and players who are at the start of there careers. Thats where we are at this stage in rebuilding the side once again.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Effort! - Positive!!!

Whilst it was a good effort I was disappointed with the inaccurate kicking, especially in the first quarter. We should have had them on the ropes early & quite possibly end up winning the game. I don't know, maybe it's having to hear that stupid Collingwood chant that made me angry.

[Missing-Dog]

Re: Effort! - Positive!!!

Whilst it was a good effort I was disappointed with the inaccurate kicking, especially in the first quarter. We should have had them on the ropes early & quite possibly end up winning the game. I don't know, maybe it's having to hear that stupid Collingwood chant that made me angry.

That chant made me angry aswell!!

This game should be ringing alarm bells for collingwood!

We had 11 players with less then 50 games inexperience. They had less then that even though they techniqually had a younger list, they had more games under there belt.

Cross, Boyd, Murphy and Gia would be atleast 3 years older then any of there players

[Bulldog4life]

Re: Effort! - Positive!!!

We likely around 9th -13th i hope.
Hope to be at least ahead of
Port, Tigers, Demons, GWS, GC, Lions
Come the end of the year.

Hope we beat Carlton again this year hehe

When it comes to the draft maybe you wish we weren't above all those teams.

[Missing-Dog]

Re: Effort! - Positive!!!

When it comes to the draft maybe you wish we weren't above all those teams.

Maybe play a few of the younger guys in teh last few rounds haha

Honestly as long as we get stuck in and beat a few bigger teams like carlton or essendon that may take us lightly then I would be happy.. and finishing 5th last would not be the end of the world but cant even see that happening see us finishing a little higher then everybody has anticipated.