Match Committee - Round 20 vs Richmond

[azabob]

Re: Match Committee - Round 20 vs Richmond

I'm happy to keep Skinner in the team next week.

I didn't see anything in Skinner today, poor hands, no where near fit enough, quite embarrassing actually how unfit he is.

What did you see in him?

[Desipura]

Re: Match Committee - Round 20 vs Richmond

Oh please no

Can we stop bagging Ves, we know you don't rate him and DJ, Im sick of the bagging.

[G-Mo77]

Re: Match Committee - Round 20 vs Richmond

What did you see in him?

Not much to be honest. He would have faired a lot better with some experienced bodies around him. We really don't have a lot to lose by playing him another week so wouldn't be upset to see him line up again. He may surprise us, he may not.

[Eastdog]

Re: Match Committee - Round 20 vs Richmond

Who makes way for Panos? Who do you think should come in and be dropped?

Most likely Zeph Skinner I would say as Rance Fan suggested. I wouldnt drop Roughead as he was very good down back for us today marking very well. I think Roughead definitely is player that has a future with us going forward.

[Desipura]

Re: Match Committee - Round 20 vs Richmond

I'm happy to keep Skinner in the team next week.

Cambell is a definite out from me. Saw a real pathetic display today, worse than Josh Hill manning the mark last year. Kicked into the man on the mark. Stood there shaking his head, not trying to win the ball back. Walked around for a bit then pretended to be sore and started stretching at the 50. Get out!!

Wood should be in the mix this week. Higgo said he was 50/50 today.

At this stage I'll call it.

Out: Campbell, DJ
In: Wood, Williams/Jones

Skinner was a non factor, Campbell did not do much however at least provided some physicality early on.

[AndrewP6]

Re: Match Committee - Round 20 vs Richmond

OUT: Skinner, Libba
IN: Coons if available. Failing that, Shermo. Williams

Not sure about Dahlhaus regarding the moon (boot) sighting.

I really like Zeph,and the notion of him becoming a successful (or even fair to middling) AFL player. But really, he's several country miles away from it. Talk about running out a game, Zeph can barely run out five minutes. He does some good things, but he is perpetually knackered. It staggers me that someone could spend a couple of years in an AFL club environment, and still lack fitness. Either he doesn't work to the level required, or the fitness staff are hopeless. To top that off, he gets a golden opportunity, and handballs it off???

The newbies did well today I thought, so I'd be OK with them all staying in the side.

[SlimPickens]

Re: Match Committee - Round 20 vs Richmond

Out: Skinner, DJ

In: Williams, sherman

Have no issue with Campbell playing the 2IC in the ruck. Williams plays forward for Skinner.

Sherman plays as DJ is a non entity

[Mofra]

Re: Match Committee - Round 20 vs Richmond

Out: Zephi, Campbell, DJ
In: Williams, Sherman, Dahlhaus

JJ & Talia stay in - saw some decent signs from both.
JJ looks set to become our Harbrow - takes the game on.

[westbulldog]

Re: Match Committee - Round 20 vs Richmond

Out Skinner
In Williams or Panos

I cannot fathom how either Veszpremi or Sherman are going to take us anywhere next year.

[Greystache]

Re: Match Committee - Round 20 vs Richmond

Out: Skinner, DJ

In: Williams, sherman

Have no issue with Campbell playing the 2IC in the ruck. Williams plays forward for Skinner.

Sherman plays as DJ is a non entity

Yep, I agree with that.

[The Underdog]

Re: Match Committee - Round 20 vs Richmond

Out: Campbell, Djerkurra

In: Williams, Dahlhaus

I know there is a call to drop Skinner and he wasn't good yesterday but I'm interested in seeing how he goes backing up from a full game. The things he did do yesterday were, present at the ball carrier (even if he couldn't hold a mark to save himself) and he put a great block on when Dylan marked and goaled in the 2nd. Realistically he's a bit off the pace but it's not like we're going to win so I'm happy to give him one more chance. Campbell is unlucky but Richmond have no 2nd ruck and with Williams coming in he and Roughy can cover the 2nd ruck job. Campbell's promotion to the list seems assured anyway.
Not sure where Wood is at.

[G-Mo77]

Re: Match Committee - Round 20 vs Richmond

So Libba is an obvious out. Tutt has injured his hammy and will miss as well. I'll have another go at my selections

Nothing was mentioned about Dahlhaus on the injury report so I'm going to assume he's good to go.

Out: Campbell, DJ, Libba, Tutt
In: Wood, Williams, Sherman, Dahlhaus

[azabob]

Re: Match Committee - Round 20 vs Richmond

So Libba is an obvious out. Tutt has injured his hammy and will miss as well. I'll have another go at my selections

Nothing was mentioned about Dahlhaus on the injury report so I'm going to assume he's good to go.

Out: Campbell, DJ, Libba, Tutt
In: Wood, Williams, Sherman, Dahlhaus

Someone mentioned Dahlhaus was in a moon boot on Saturday night. Do we even know why Sherman was a late withdrawal?

[Missing Dog]

Re: Match Committee - Round 20 vs Richmond

In Wood Dahlhaus Williams Moles (Give the guy One more chance cant hurt)
Out Libba Campbell Tutt Dj

[G-Mo77]

Re: Match Committee - Round 20 vs Richmond

Someone mentioned Dahlhaus was in a moon boot on Saturday night. Do we even know why Sherman was a late withdrawal?

Yeah that was me. Heard that on the radio. Sherman was sick wasn't he or was that Williams. I watched the video 5 minutes ago and it's already escaped my mind.