TAC Cup Future Stars Phantom Draft

[comrade]

Re: TAC Cup Future Stars Phantom Draft

I've seen a little bit of Temel - he's a solidly built young guy and is capable of clunking some big grabs up forward.

I've heard Panos is very similar to Pavlich at the same age - if he's still available, he might be worth a very hard look (even though I believe we need to either go for defensive cover or a speedy midfielder).

[AndrewP6]

Re: TAC Cup Future Stars Phantom Draft

Some more talls

Levi Casboult - 196cm from the Dandenong Stingrays
Matthew Panos - 192cm from Norwood
Kyle Hartigan - 193cm from the Western Jets
David Astbury - 193cm from the North Ballarat Rebels
Serhat Temel - 194cm from the Calder Cannons
Luke McDonald 195cm from the Eastern Ranges
Sam Reid - 192cm from the Murray Bushrangers

Could we cope with two in the same side?

[GVGjr]

Re: TAC Cup Future Stars Phantom Draft

I've seen a little bit of Temel - he's a solidly built young guy and is capable of clunking some big grabs up forward.

I've heard Panos is very similar to Pavlich at the same age - if he's still available, he might be worth a very hard look (even though I believe we need to either go for defensive cover or a speedy midfielder).

I think he could also play as a key defender and I think he would be worth a look at later in the draft.

Panos didn't have a great carnival so it's a bit hard to judge him but he has no fundamental flaws and will be a first round consideration.

If you can think of some other guys worthy as a mention just list them and I'll build a more comprehensive list later on.

We will no doubt do one of those phantom drafts again this year which a lot of people really enjoyed.

[GVGjr]

Re: TAC Cup Future Stars Phantom Draft

Could we cope with two in the same side?

Son of former Bulldog Bruce Reid by the way. Bruce never played enough games for him to be a F/S chance.

He's a very athletic player probably better suited to the back line.

[AndrewP6]

Re: TAC Cup Future Stars Phantom Draft

Son of former Bulldog Bruce Reid by the way. Bruce never played enough games for him to be a F/S chance.

He's a very athletic player probably better suited to the back line.

Thanks... I think two Sam Reids in one team would be very amusing...and confusing!

[Happy Days]

Re: TAC Cup Future Stars Phantom Draft

Some more talls

Levi Casboult - 196cm from the Dandenong Stingrays
Matthew Panos - 192cm from Norwood
Kyle Hartigan - 193cm from the Western Jets
David Astbury - 193cm from the North Ballarat Rebels
Serhat Temel - 194cm from the Calder Cannons
Luke McDonald 195cm from the Eastern Ranges
Sam Reid - 192cm from the Murray Bushrangers

Have gotten word from a mate playing for Eastern that this kid is an absolute gun, and a phenominal kick for goal (has kicked something like 80.13 for the season - i've got a feeling this might be an overstatement, but impressive none the less.)

However, no state representation at the carnival has me skeptical.

[GVGjr]

Re: TAC Cup Future Stars Phantom Draft

Have gotten word from a mate playing for Eastern that this kid is an absolute gun, and a phenominal kick for goal (has kicked something like 80.13 for the season - i've got a feeling this might be an overstatement, but impressive none the less.)

However, no state representation at the carnival has me skeptical.

He is an overage player much like Jayden Post was last year for the Jets so he was never eligible to be selected for Vic Metro.

The query on him is his pace. He has kicked a few bags of goals but often when the better players were absent with the Vic Country and Metro duties.

With a shallow draft, especially for talls, and some compromised drafts just about upon us there might be a few teams interested. Could be a nice rookie list pick up.

[GVGjr]

Re: TAC Cup Future Stars Phantom Draft

Smokies and Tall Utilities

Troy Taylor - 188cm from South Alice Springs
Chris Luff - 193cm from Peel Thunder
Nicholas Winmar - 190cm from Claremont
Andrew Moore - 188cm from the Eastern Ranges
Mitchell Brown - 192cm from Peel Thunder
Luke Thompson - 193cm from the Geelong Falcons
Aaron Black - 195cm from Peel Thunder
Nat Fyfe - 186cm - from Claremont

[AndrewP6]

Re: TAC Cup Future Stars Phantom Draft

Smokies and Tall Utilities

Troy Taylor - 188cm from South Alice Springs
Chris Luff - 193cm from Peel Thunder
Nicholas Winmar - 190cm from Claremont
Andrew Moore - 188cm from the Eastern Ranges
Mitchell Brown - 192cm from Peel Thunder
Luke Thompson - 193cm from the Geelong Falcons
Aaron Black - 195cm from Peel Thunder
Nat Fyfe - 186cm - from Claremont

Seriously??? Another Nicky Winmar? Sorry to drag this serious thread down!...

[GVGjr]

Re: TAC Cup Future Stars Phantom Draft

Seriously??? Another Nicky Winmar? Sorry to drag this serious thread down!...

A relation. Not a son but a relation of Nicky. This guys is a great mover and has a bit of the x-factor about him.

[GVGjr]

Re: TAC Cup Future Stars Phantom Draft

Tall midfielders and mid sized Utilties

Anthony Morabito - 190cm from Peel Thunder
Andrew Moore - 188cm from Eastern Ranges
Mitchell Duncan - 186cm from East Perth
Koby Stevens - 187cm from Gippsland Power
Bradley Sheppard 186cm from East Fremantle
Jordon Gysberst - 188cm from Eastern Ranges
Gary Rohan - 186cm from Geelong Falcons
Michael Thompson - 186cm from Oakleigh Chargers

[comrade]

Re: TAC Cup Future Stars Phantom Draft

Tall midfielders and mid sized Utilties

Anthony Morabito - 190cm from Peel Thunder
Andrew Moore - 188cm from Eastern Ranges
Mitchell Duncan - 186cm from East Perth
Koby Stevens - 187cm from Gippsland Power
Bradley Sheppard 186cm from East Fremantle
Jordon Gysberst - 188cm from Eastern Ranges
Gary Rohan - 186cm from Geelong Falcons
Michael Thompson - 186cm from Oakleigh Chargers

I haven't seen much of Duncan but I keep hearing very good things - rated as a late first rd pick. What are your thoughts?

[GVGjr]

Re: TAC Cup Future Stars Phantom Draft

I haven't seen much of Duncan but I keep hearing very good things - rated as a late first rd pick. What are your thoughts?

He's a good player. Composed, long kick and a good decision maker. Late 1st round or early 2nd in my opinion. Could be available when we have our pick but he's not a gun midfielder or a KPP. More of a goal kicking utility.

The knock on him is that he isn't regarded as a high possession winner.

[mjp]

Re: TAC Cup Future Stars Phantom Draft

A relation. Not a son but a relation of Nicky. This guys is a great mover and has a bit of the x-factor about him.

Not yesterday he wasn't.

I shouldn't gloat!

[comrade]

Re: TAC Cup Future Stars Phantom Draft

Not yesterday he wasn't.

I shouldn't gloat!

Putting yesterday aside, do you rate Winmar as a 2nd or 3rd round pick?

I've heard the biggest knock on him is his current fitness base - just doesn't get to enough contests and fades out of games. Sound about right?