GD's Top 20 2014 Draft

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Go_Dogs
    Hall of Fame
    • Jan 2007
    • 10075

    GD's Top 20 2014 Draft

    It's a very interesting draft this year, a lot of players who have claims on being in the top 20 and I'm going to have to leave quite a few out who will get drafted in that range this year.

    1. Patrick McCartin - 196cm 96kgs - Key Forward
    The number one prospect this year for mine. Tall forward who has been a proven performer at the U/18 level for the past 2 years. Good size, hands and loves taking a mark. Will probably play his best footy closer to goal than being someone who roams too far, at least at this stage. Think he will be gone inside the first 3 on draft day, and Melbourne seem the most likely.

    2. Christian Petracca - 186cm 96kgs - Midfield/Utility
    He has shot to the favourite for being the first player selected in a few weeks times based on 2014 season. He projects as a powerful, goal kicking midfielder who can turn games with ball winning ability, his pace and game sense. Think he will be playing for the Saints next season.

    3. Isaac Heeney - 186cm 84kgs - Midfielder

    Swans Academy player who ticks all the boxes as a complete midfielder who is good inside and out. Will be a high production player at AFL level, and comfortable playing a range of roles through the midfield. Great vision and decision making, along with his disposal skills will mean he is an offensive weapon. Already taken by Sydney at 18, a bargain.

    4. Peter Wright - 203cm 100kgs - Ruck/Key Forward

    It seems Wright is slipping a bit at the moment, as a few others bolt up the order late which is usually the case. Wright is a great size, strong and positions himself well in a marking contest. He needs to get a bit better and making the most of his hard work in positioning himself and leading to the right spots. When he takes possession he is a thumping kick and loves a goal. I see him being a ruck/forward at AFL level and the type of player who can share his time equally in both roles. If GWS don't jump (and they don't really take rucks early), perhaps he is more in the frame for Geelong at 10 or even Richmond at 12. Collingwood may surprise and jump at 5.

    5. Angus Brayshaw - 187cm 90kgs - Midfielder
    Another midfielder who ticks a lot of boxes, and is a great size. Will be able to play inside and out, his contested game and disposal, off either side, will be highlights. Not afraid of a goal, and a good mark for his size. Will eventually become a high production midfielder as he gets stronger and fitter. I think he will be Melbourne bound, but if not hard to see him getting past Collingwood at 5.

    6. Jarrod Pickett - 177cm 75kgs - Midfielder/Utility
    An impressive young player whose speed testing confirmed what most suspected, he's a jet who'll be hard to catch at AFL level. Will play his best football receiving the ball and bursting away, linking through the middle and creating scoring opportunities, or kicking them himself. Can win his own ball, and suspect he'll develop the ability to play inside the square and be effective. Excitement machine, who'll break games open. I suspect WC will snare him at 11, but wouldn't put it past GC having a crack at 8 and thinking they can make him a long term player and add to their crop of exciting WA players.

    7. Darcy Moore - 199cm 91kgs - Key Position/Utility
    Darcy was super impressive towards the back end of the TAC Cup season, including the finals, and that is what I think of when I see his name. Very athletic, competitive player who will be able to influence games at both ends of the ground and around the ball. Needs to improve his strength, and be more consistent with his disposal, but can roost a ball and is otherwise a great prospect. Collingwood have taken him under F/S with pick 9.

    8. Jayden Laverde - 189cm 80kgs - Midfielder/Half Back

    A skillful athlete who looks like he can develop into an inside-outside midfielder at AFL, but will have the versatility to start his career off a flank. Can impact the scoreboard, and will be a bloke who will run and carry, and then execute a good kick. Good size for the modern game, and may end up being similar to Macrae with his size and skill set. He's one I see GWS taking at either 6 or 7, but definitely gone inside the first 10 picks.

    9. Hugh Goddard - 196cm 94kgs - Key Position

    Goddard will most likely end up being a key defender at AFL level, but has shown he can play at both ends. After a relatively quiet year after being touted as a top 5 pick in his under-age season, he came good towards the end to remind recruiters he's a great athlete who can defend and roost a ball. His testing proved he will be capable of running with the best, and quickest key forwards. Needs to improve his decision making with ball in hand, but think he has the skills to become a long term AFL player. The Crows at 14 I think would be a good fit, and Gold Coast are a chance at 15.

    10. Jake Lever - 193cm 84kgs - Key Defender

    I find it hard to rate him any higher, but don't want to put him any lower. Hasn't played much footy which has possibly helped his cause in recruiters eyes, as the potential is there without being able to judge it against others who came on this year. Seems like he is a reasonable athlete, although don't look to his DC testing, as it was very ordinary. Risk with his injury history, but a player who is rated highly for his leadership and approach to his rehab. I tend to think GWS will jump in the first 7 picks.
    Have you heard Butters wants to come to the Dogs?
  • Go_Dogs
    Hall of Fame
    • Jan 2007
    • 10075

    #2
    Re: GD's Top 20 2014 Draft

    11. Sam Durdin - 197cm 88kgs - Key Position
    Another who has had a somewhat down year, due to a slow start with injury. Hard to see him developing into anything other than a key defender at AFL level, and may end up being similar to Port's Trengove, in that he will be able to chop out in the ruck a bit if need be. Has some physical development to do, but tested reasonably well for a big fella with his speed, he's a good mark and he's versatile. I see him landing between 12-20 on draft day, and think Richmond, Freo and Crows are perhaps the best chances.

    12. Tom Lamb - 193cm 84kgs - Utility
    I'm a big fan of his talent. He's competitive in the contest, both in the air and at ground level. He's a great athlete, with good speed for a big bloke but outstanding endurance. I think his skills are solid, he just needs to take a bit more care at times. His decision making is good, he'll be a capable defender and tackler if the application is there. Ultimately, he projects as a utility who can play anywhere, including taking a turn through the middle. I'd love his package at the Dogs. Super hard to predict where he may go, given he's a top 15 player on talent but likely to be more in the range or Essendon, St Kilda, GWS or us late first round early second.

    13. Liam Duggan - 184cm 75kgs - Midfielder/Flanker
    His athletic testing is the major knock I have on him, but I think he appears to move OK on the field, so I'm not quite sure what to make of it. A well rounded player who can do a bit of everything, his disposal is good, he's solid inside and out and capable of defending. Should become a good inside-out midfielder who can accumulate the ball and use it well by foot. He seems a type Richmond may go for, and wouldn't be surprised to see Essendon or Carlton jump late first round.

    14. Clem Smith - 177cm 77kgs - Midfielder/Flanker

    A small defender at U/18 level who impressed with his carnival last year as an under-age player which is what sees him still sitting so high in my rankings. His attack on the ball and body is fierce, and he has some wheels. Needs to work on his disposal to more consistently hit targets, although I suspect he'll become a reliable user and isn't as bad as some media scribes would have you believe. No idea where he sits, but expect he'll be gone by Freo at 34 at the latest. Could hold some appeal for us, and North may be another team that like his combination of hardness and speed.

    15. Caleb Marchbank - 192cm 89kgs - Utility

    Perhaps not quite genuine key position size, but suited more as a third tall who could perhaps develop into a guy who can take a run through the middle too. Good athlete, who can play as a stopper but also generate run and use the ball well himself. Shame he didn't complete the testing at DC, but suspect he'd have done well. Given he's young may still have a bit of growing to do (Dec 1996 birthday). Another I see going somewhere between Richmond at 12 and GWS at 24, Fremantle a big chance and think Essendon would be keen too.

    16. Alex Neal-Bullen - 182cm 76kgs - Midfielder
    Great SA prospect who is a contested ball player who will accumulate all day. His agility testing was good, which bodes well for his inside game and work around congestion given his speed isn't great. Strong endurance athlete. Needs to tighten up his disposal a little and put his great endurance to better use by becoming an efficient outside player with ability to link up and hit targets consistently, but think he'll be able to do that. Crows at 35 are a good chance if he's available, otherwise expect he could appeal to North, GWS or St Kilda.

    17. Damien Cavka - 185cm 79kgs - Utility

    A difficult one to place, he has great endurance and is a good size, although is predominately viewed as a forward player who can run through the middle, and is very outside. I think he can eventually develop into an outside-in midfielder who accumulates the ball, impacts the scoreboard and runs and carries with speed. In the modern game, he's the type of player I'd be backing in to have a long career because of those projections, but it's a bit of a mystery as to where he may end up. Probably in the 20-40 range and could appeal to a few clubs, Hawks and Sydney the best chances for mine.

    18. Jack Lonie - 174cm 69kgs - Small Forward/Midfielder

    Not going to be a top 20 pick because of his size, but he was the player I was most impressed with over the TAC Cup finals series. He can mark, he can impact the scoreboard and change the course of the game very quickly. Reads the play well, and is comfortable in the air for his size. Good player at ground level, in that he can quickly assess the options, take the right one and execute his skills. I think he can be like Dahlhaus, in that eventually with his tricks it would be a shame to see him not become a midfielder, but also has a bit of Ballantyne about him. He's probably in that 30-50 range on draft day, and someone is going to get a bargain.

    19. Dean Gore - 182cm 86kgs - Midfielder

    A ready to go SA player who is a great athlete and will be able to step into league footy pretty quickly with his contested ball and defensive abilities. Good kick, penetrating. Will win his own ball or receive inside and be able to create space for himself. Needs to become more damaging on the outside and a better accumulator of 'easy ball'. Can mark, and kick a goal but will divide opinion of recruiters because of the view he has less upside. Suspect he'll be around the mark from 25-45 and think we'll be in the mix.

    20. Nakia Cockatoo - 186cm 86kgs - Utility/Midfielder

    One who I hadn't seen but have taken a lot of time to learn more about him after his exceptional testing at the DC and hearing about his exploits late in the year in the exhibition match. An eye catching player, who looks to have a very transferable skill-set with his speed, agility and skills by hand and foot. He's going to be a player who can tear open games and impact the scoreboard. It seems North have invested quite a bit of time into him and may jump early in the second round. I suspect he'll be off the table by 40 but another who its a little unclear where he may end up.
    Have you heard Butters wants to come to the Dogs?

    Comment

    • Go_Dogs
      Hall of Fame
      • Jan 2007
      • 10075

      #3
      Re: GD's Top 20 2014 Draft

      As always, it's just personal opinion based on what I've seen over the past couple of years, and what I have read and gleamed from discussions with others. Bound to get plenty wrong, and as I said in the opening, plenty of good players who haven't been included who will go on to have long, successful careers, such is how even the crop of 2014 will end up.
      Have you heard Butters wants to come to the Dogs?

      Comment

      • Throughandthrough
        Coaching Staff
        • Nov 2007
        • 3203

        #4
        Re: GD's Top 20 2014 Draft

        Hooray. Is it Petracca who has diabetes? That alone may see him scare one or two clubs away.

        Comment

        • Go_Dogs
          Hall of Fame
          • Jan 2007
          • 10075

          #5
          Re: GD's Top 20 2014 Draft

          Originally posted by Throughandthrough
          Hooray. Is it Petracca who has diabetes? That alone may see him scare one or two clubs away.
          McCartin. It doesn't appear it will impact his standings much.
          Have you heard Butters wants to come to the Dogs?

          Comment

          • Remi Moses
            WOOF Member
            • Jan 2009
            • 14785

            #6
            Re: GD's Top 20 2014 Draft

            There's a whisper that 2 metre Peter is going to slide to 10.
            Suspicious how Geelong improved their draft position

            Comment

            • GVGjr
              Moderator
              • Nov 2006
              • 43906

              #7
              Re: GD's Top 20 2014 Draft

              Great list there GD and a number of surprises. The likes of Ahern, Weller, Langford, Blakely and DeGoey are all strong top 20 candidates.

              Just to expand your views, where would you have Reece McKenzie going?
              Even though we spent a fortune to get Tom Boyd I wonder if there is still room for a player like McKenzie with us? As you are aware, some of his Combine results indicate there is a bit to work with.
              Western Bulldogs Football Club "Where it's cool to drool"

              Comment

              • Go_Dogs
                Hall of Fame
                • Jan 2007
                • 10075

                #8
                Re: GD's Top 20 2014 Draft

                Originally posted by GVGjr
                Great list there GD and a number of surprises. The likes of Ahern, Weller, Langford, Blakely and DeGoey are all strong top 20 candidates.
                I'm pretty certain guys like Weller, Langford and Blakely will go around the top 20 mark on draft day, and they are all excellent prospects. Ahern and DeGoey have probably dropped a little bit in my ratings as whilst they were OK I don't think they stood out in the TAC Cup finals - I would have been more confident about them if they'd done a little more. That said, I'm sure they will get drafted early and have good chances of becoming long term AFL players.

                Originally posted by GVGjr
                Just to expand your views, where would you have Reece McKenzie going?
                Even though we spent a fortune to get Tom Boyd I wonder if there is still room for a player like McKenzie with us? As you are aware, some of his Combine results indicate there is a bit to work with.
                I really struggled with McKenzie and exactly where he fits in. I probably rate him in the 25-30 range myself.

                On the back of his testing, most have him rising quickly (and his results were impressive). Given St Kilda will take Petracca at 1, I suspect they are well positioned to take a punt on McKenzie at 21/22 and GWS are a chance just afterwards. Given Essendon have lost Ryder, they might also be in the mix.

                If he was available at our selection, I think he warrants consideration, but it depends on which running players slip through. My preference is to take running players at 26 and 27, unless the ones we really want are gone.
                Have you heard Butters wants to come to the Dogs?

                Comment

                • Go_Dogs
                  Hall of Fame
                  • Jan 2007
                  • 10075

                  #9
                  Re: GD's Top 20 2014 Draft

                  Originally posted by Remi Moses
                  There's a whisper that 2 metre Peter is going to slide to 10.
                  Suspicious how Geelong improved their draft position
                  I read something this morning Essendon could be in the mix for him.

                  Amazing stuff if he drifts out that far, surely he won't - although I said the same thing about Grundy a couple of years ago who I rated as the 4th best prospect...
                  Have you heard Butters wants to come to the Dogs?

                  Comment

                  • GVGjr
                    Moderator
                    • Nov 2006
                    • 43906

                    #10
                    Re: GD's Top 20 2014 Draft

                    I keep looking at our list next for next year and with the players that have moved to other sides players we draft this year can play significant time next season.

                    Looking at the players that didn't make GD's top 20 (and understanding he's not saying this is the way clubs will draft players) there will be some very good prospects still available at our selections. If we get this right some of these guys will get a lot of senior experience.
                    Western Bulldogs Football Club "Where it's cool to drool"

                    Comment

                    • GVGjr
                      Moderator
                      • Nov 2006
                      • 43906

                      #11
                      Re: GD's Top 20 2014 Draft

                      Just as a comparison Jay Clark and Sam Landsberger have put up their top 20. Obviously they have theirs in the like draft orders:

                      1. Petracca
                      2. Brayshaw
                      3. McCartin
                      4. De Goey
                      5. Laverde
                      6. Goddard
                      7. Pickett
                      8. Langford
                      9. Moore
                      10. Lever
                      11. Ahern
                      12. Duggan
                      13. Durdin
                      14. Wright
                      15. Garlett
                      16. Cockatoo
                      17. Weller
                      18. Heeney
                      19. Marchbank
                      20. Lamb
                      Western Bulldogs Football Club "Where it's cool to drool"

                      Comment

                      • Go_Dogs
                        Hall of Fame
                        • Jan 2007
                        • 10075

                        #12
                        Re: GD's Top 20 2014 Draft

                        DeGoey seems to be rising very quickly. Do you see him as a legitimate top 5 selection GVGjr?
                        Have you heard Butters wants to come to the Dogs?

                        Comment

                        • GVGjr
                          Moderator
                          • Nov 2006
                          • 43906

                          #13
                          Re: GD's Top 20 2014 Draft

                          Originally posted by Go_Dogs
                          DeGoey seems to be rising very quickly. Do you see him as a legitimate top 5 selection GVGjr?
                          No I don't, good player though.
                          Western Bulldogs Football Club "Where it's cool to drool"

                          Comment

                          • Remi Moses
                            WOOF Member
                            • Jan 2009
                            • 14785

                            #14
                            Re: GD's Top 20 2014 Draft

                            How does a player go from top
                            5 and potential 1, to pick 20?

                            Comment

                            • GVGjr
                              Moderator
                              • Nov 2006
                              • 43906

                              #15
                              Re: GD's Top 20 2014 Draft

                              Originally posted by Remi Moses
                              How does a player go from top
                              5 and potential 1, to pick 20?
                              It's the media trying to do the numbers and speculating that some teams don't want to wait a couple of years for KPP to develop.
                              Wright is too good of a footballer to slide far in my opinion. Geelong probably have some good reasons not to select him given the way they have topped up on KPP but I'd still be surprised if he slipped past them.
                              Western Bulldogs Football Club "Where it's cool to drool"

                              Comment

                              Working...