Other Club Delistings 2017 - Any interest.

[Topdog]

Re: Other Club Delistings 2017 - Any interest.

I've responded to why I don't think the Buckley and Clayton comparison is a good one. I don't particularly care about Buckley.

You don't think Clayton's list of failures deserves some media scrutiny? I'd say he has been under delivering on strong positions in the drafts for more than a little while now and coaches are losing their jobs but Clayton remains. At some point someone will wise up.

He deserves to lose his job and should have done so 3 years ago. Media never really talk about a recruiter but there has been plenty of talk that the GC list is not good enough

[Bornadog]

Re: Other Club Delistings 2017 - Any interest.

He deserves to lose his job and should have done so 3 years ago. Media never really talk about a recruiter but there has been plenty of talk that the GC list is not good enough

Clayton has been the List manager at GC for some time now, but agree he needs to come under scrutiny.

I would say the whole club is under review at the moment, so he and the recruiters need to be looked at.

[Topdog]

Re: Other Club Delistings 2017 - Any interest.

Clayton has been the List manager at GC for some time now, but agree he needs to come under scrutiny.

I would say the whole club is under review at the moment, so he and the recruiters need to be looked at.

Yep and the list is poor and their trades are not great.

[Bornadog]

Re: Other Club Delistings 2017 - Any interest.

Latest List - 12 Sept

ADELAIDE
Scott Thompson (retired)

BRISBANE
Ryan Harwood (delisted)
Jarrad Jansen (delisted)
Jonathan Freeman (delisted)
Josh Clayton (delisted)
Blake Grewar (delisted)

CARLTON
Denis Armfield (retired)
Daniel Gorringe (retired)
Matthew Korcheck (retired)
Kristian Jaksch (delisted)
Liam Sumner (delisted)
Andrew Gallucci (delisted)

COLLINGWOOD
Jesse White (retired)

ESSENDON
Jobe Watson (retired)
James Kelly (retired)
Yestin Eades (retired)
Brent Stanton (retired)

FREMANTLE
Shane Yarran (retired)
Zac Dawson (retired)
Garrick Ibbotson (retired)

GEELONG
Tom Lonergan (retired)
Andrew Mackie (retired)

GOLD COAST
Jarrad Grant (delisted)
Mitch Hallahan (delisted)
Keegan Brooksby (delisted)
Ryan Davis (delisted)
Cameron Loersch (delisted)

GWS GIANTS
Steve Johnson (retired)
Tom Downie (retired)

HAWTHORN
Luke Hodge (retired)
Josh Gibson (retired)
Jack Fitzpatrick (retired)
Luke Surman (retired)

MELBOURNE
Heritier Lumumba (retired)

NORTH MELBOURNE
Lachie Hansen (delisted)
Will Fordham (delisted)
Matt Taylor (delisted)

PORT ADELAIDE
---

RICHMOND
Ivan Maric (retired)
Chris Yarran (retired)

ST KILDA
Nick Riewoldt (retired)
Sean Dempster (retired)
Leigh Montagna (retired)
Nick Coughlan (delisted)
Joe Baker-Thoms (delisted)

SYDNEY

---

WEST COAST
Sam Mitchell (retired)
Matthew Priddis (retired)
Paddy Brophy (retired)
Sam Butler (retired)
Drew Petrie (retired)

Update

[Happy Days]

Re: Other Club Delistings 2017 - Any interest.

That is a bleak list of cuts at Brisbane.

[ledge]

Re: Other Club Delistings 2017 - Any interest.

Kristian Jaksch would be the biggest dissapointment ever.
He was a top pick from what I remember and didn't even make it at Carlton ..
I wonder what his downfall was.

[Bornadog]

Re: Other Club Delistings 2017 - Any interest.

Port Adelaide has eight players still without contracts for next season as end-of-year reviews continue

Extract:

PORT Adelaide has eight players in the end-of-season reviews at Alberton without AFL contracts for next year.

They are free-agent utility Jackson Trengove, seasoned trio Angus Monfries, Nathan Krakouer and Matt White, forward Aaron Young who has become accustomed to one-year deals and novices Brendon AhChee, Aidyn Johnson and Jesse Palmer.

[1eyedog]

Re: Other Club Delistings 2017 - Any interest.

Melbourne has delisted Jack Trengove I'm open to throwing him a lifeline.

[Axe Man]

Re: Other Club Delistings 2017 - Any interest.

Melbourne has delisted Jack Trengove I'm open to throwing him a lifeline.

That will cause mass confusion if we get Jackson Trengove as well!

[ledge]

Re: Other Club Delistings 2017 - Any interest.

That will cause mass confusion if we get Jackson Trengove as well!

Bit of luck the umpires get confused to and one wins a Brownlow ;-)

[Happy Days]

Re: Other Club Delistings 2017 - Any interest.

Jack Trengove is so finished; incredibly slow, Smithian turning circle, doesn't use the ball well and just isn't good. It's sad to see such a promising player fail but he's a list clogger at this stage.

[comrade]

Re: Other Club Delistings 2017 - Any interest.

I'd have a look at Coughlan from St Kilda. Played at Footscray a few years back and looked a likely type, but never got a crack with the Saints.

[GVGjr]

Re: Other Club Delistings 2017 - Any interest.

Melbourne has delisted Jack Trengove I'm open to throwing him a lifeline.

He still has a bit to give. At the very least he would be good for the younger players

[Ozza]

Re: Other Club Delistings 2017 - Any interest.

Clayton has been the List manager at GC for some time now, but agree he needs to come under scrutiny.

I would say the whole club is under review at the moment, so he and the recruiters need to be looked at.

Yep, Gold Coast has been pretty disastrous all round - but the list management/recruiting really stands out.
I find it pretty strange the venom with which people chose to lay the boots into GWS about the club and the players after they lost last week's final - when you consider the cavernous gap between what they have been able to do in nearly 6 seasons, compared to Gold Coast's 8. And a lot of it comes down to recruiting the right kind of players from the draft, and targeting the right kind of mature players from opposition clubs.

Gold Coast selections have been baffling at times. Just heaps of classic Clayton-esque skinny athletic types who are lacking in the contested footy, or footy-smarts department.

[Topdog]

Re: Other Club Delistings 2017 - Any interest.

Ozza, GWS actually had more hand outs than GC and are arrogant flogs