Proactive Poaching

[Grantysghost]

Re: Proactive Poaching

So who else are you going to put up? I can't see us palming Mitch off when we just signed him up. We just wouldn't do it and I don't think we should. If you're talking players who would you send up there to appease them in a player swap involving Martin? Victorian boy and Premiership player McLean? Assuming Williams is going home...

I think we can pretty much say that Dicko, Suckers, Dale and R Smith have close to zero collateral as well so it has to be someone good.

It's a very good question. Wallis appears to be not in our current plans, so I guess it's hard to look past him. He has the protection of a contract so it would be his call I guess. I can't see him wanting to play his prime years at Footscray.

Edit : I now realise Mitch is injured (thanks for the heads up!), so basically forget everything I just said

[Bornadog]

Re: Proactive Poaching

Wallis appears to be not in our current plans,

What makes you say that?

[Axe Man]

Re: Proactive Poaching

It's a very good question. Wallis appears to be not in our current plans, so I guess it's hard to look past him. He has the protection of a contract so it would be his call I guess. I can't see him wanting to play his prime years at Footscray.

He played 10 games straight until he was injured. Only played in the VFL when he resumed and was obviously not ready for AFL.

[Grantysghost]

Re: Proactive Poaching

What makes you say that?

My bad bad, I hadn't realised he was injured with an ankle.Thought he was in the VFL I should follow it more closely, it's his brother. Maybe he is in our plans

My point is really around the Suns and them getting players in return for Martin, instead of picks. Of course they could turn that pick into a player in a three way deal, that would be better for them I feel.

[Bulldog Joe]

Re: Proactive Poaching

It's a very good question. Wallis appears to be not in our current plans, so I guess it's hard to look past him. He has the protection of a contract so it would be his call I guess. I can't see him wanting to play his prime years at Footscray.

Wallis has only been out of the side due to injury. Even when he played a couple in the VFL it was to see if he could play through the problem he had.

There has been nothing to suggest he is out of favour.

Edit.
Didn't see Axe Man's post until after I posted.

[Grantysghost]

Re: Proactive Poaching

He played 10 games straight until he was injured. Only played in the VFL when he resumed and was obviously not ready for AFL.

Yeah just had a look he played the two games in the VFL rd 14 v Tigers, and rd 15 v Casey and performed pretty well in both but as you say ankle didn't come up. I wrongly thought he was still playing VFL.

[Axe Man]

Re: Proactive Poaching

Of course they could turn that pick into a player in a three way deal, that would be better for them I feel.

I think this is more likely since we don't really have many players with currency that we would be willing to deal. Perhaps Williams if he isn't set on going back to Adelaide. Maybe Lynch?

[Grantysghost]

Re: Proactive Poaching

I think this is more likely since we don't really have many players with currency that we would be willing to deal. Perhaps Williams if he isn't set on going back to Adelaide. Maybe Lynch?

I had a good look through the list myself and it is a very tough exercise I don't envy Sam Power and his team. They can have Jerka Jenkins. Martin to Dogs, Pick 10 to Crows, Gibbs and Jenkins to GCS.

[The Adelaide Connection]

Re: Proactive Poaching

I had a good look through the list myself and it is a very tough exercise I don't envy Sam Power and his team. They can have Jerka Jenkins. Martin to Dogs, Pick 10 to Crows, Gibbs and Jenkins to GCS.

Oh hell no. I would rather give GC pick 10 outright than see the Crows profit pick 10 for two players they want to delist and salary dump.

BUT if we were to give GC 10 for Martin I would want at least a third rounder coming back.

[Twodogs]

Re: Proactive Poaching

Oh hell no. I would rather give GC pick 10 outright than see the Crows profit pick 10 for two players they want to delist and salary dump.

BUT if we were to give GC 10 for Martin I would want at least a third rounder coming back.

I was quite happy to see Adelaide piss away draft picks on Gibbs and I'd hate to see them protected from their own stupidity.

[GVGjr]

Re: Proactive Poaching

Oh hell no. I would rather give GC pick 10 outright than see the Crows profit pick 10 for two players they want to delist and salary dump.

BUT if we were to give GC 10 for Martin I would want at least a third rounder coming back.

A straight up swap is a fair outcome for mine and at the moment I think GC has a lateish 3rd round pick (49). If we would swing that from them then it would be a terrific outcome as we would have 4 x 3rd round picks and that would create many options for us

They do have a 2nd first round pick which might come into play in some way

[Remi Moses]

Re: Proactive Poaching

Jack Martin’s going to have to improve some of his lacklustre efforts
Especially last week

[Rocket Science]

Re: Proactive Poaching

Don't knock the lad he's conveniently driving his price down.

[Testekill]

Re: Proactive Poaching

Is he really worth pick 8-10?

He is not, I'd say he's worth a pick from 18-23 but we can't do that. I guess trying to turn our first into the 2nd rounder and Martin might not be too bad.

[GVGjr]

Re: Proactive Poaching

Jack Martin’s going to have to improve some of his lacklustre efforts
Especially last week

As Rocket Science mentioned, it could be a bonus for us.
Martin may have checked out now which isn't a good sign but I'd imagine he is still very much in our sights