Melbourne Watch 2023/24

[hujsh]

Re: Melbourne Watch 2023

I am currently overseas on a trip and one of our companions is a bit Melbourne tragic.
The message she is getting from fellow Demon supporters is that the current issues are somehow related to Lachie Hunter.

Have we placed Lachie in the Melbourne camp to infiltrate and destroy as an undercover agent?

Supposedly these issues have been there in some form or another since 2020 or earlier (when the president wanted to sack Goodwin) so if Hunter has played any role it's just been in making the existing wound fester a bit more.

I do like the idea though

[Sedat]

Re: Melbourne Watch 2023

In terms of the Demon's star-studded list and their list management in general, I wouldn't want to forget that the current iteration of their team was built on some fairly preferential treatment over the years by the AFL, either through act or omission. Being allowed to keep high draft picks on the back of tanking (e.g., 2013), extremely generous compensations for departed players (think Scully, Frawley...), some very dodgy draft manoeuvring (Jack Viney), gifted a high-profile coach...

North Melbourne are currently trying their best to imitate the Melbourne FC model. If, in a few years time, the Kangaroos have an almighty list that are winning premierships for fun, I will be similarly reserved in my praise for their achievements.

No doubt about it, they had enormous assistance early doors in their list build as you have highlighted above. They did then start to nail their picks as well to be fair. All up, it makes their under-achievement since 2019 even more apparent.

I can also see North following a similar trajectory, especially if they nail their picks for the next couple of years. They sure have had a fair old leg-up from City Hall.

[Grantysghost]

Re: Melbourne Watch 2023

Supposedly these issues have been there in some form or another since 2020 or earlier (when the president wanted to sack Goodwin) so if Hunter has played any role it's just been in making the existing wound fester a bit more.

I do like the idea though

Yes, you just to have to search Glenn Bartlett and you'll find all you need.

[ReLoad]

Re: Melbourne Watch 2023

I say, terrible business ol’ chap. One simply doesn’t air one’s dirty laundry for all and sundry.

It reminds me of the time the chateau la tour ‘63 was corked.

Frightful business, I’m heading down to Sorrento for a few months til this all blows over.

[KT31]

Re: Melbourne Watch 2023

I say, terrible business ol’ chap. One simply doesn’t air one’s dirty laundry for all and sundry.

It reminds me of the time the chateau la tour ‘63 was corked.

Frightful business, I’m heading down to Sorrento for a few months til this all blows over.

Is it wrong that I read this in my head as Doctor Bombay?

[Testekill]

Re: Melbourne Watch 2023

I am currently overseas on a trip and one of our companions is a bit Melbourne tragic.
The message she is getting from fellow Demon supporters is that the current issues are somehow related to Lachie Hunter.

Have we placed Lachie in the Melbourne camp to infiltrate and destroy as an undercover agent?

The rot was there years ago considering that the president openly wanted to fire Goodwin.

[Twodogs]

Re: Melbourne Watch 2023

I am currently overseas on a trip and one of our companions is a bit Melbourne tragic.
The message she is getting from fellow Demon supporters is that the current issues are somehow related to Lachie Hunter.

Have we placed Lachie in the Melbourne camp to infiltrate and destroy as an undercover agent?

Lachie is like a cuckoo in the nest?

[Twodogs]

Re: Melbourne Watch 2023

In terms of the Demon's star-studded list and their list management in general, I wouldn't want to forget that the current iteration of their team was built on some fairly preferential treatment over the years by the AFL, either through act or omission. Being allowed to keep high draft picks on the back of tanking (e.g., 2013), extremely generous compensations for departed players (think Scully, Frawley...), some very dodgy draft manoeuvring (Jack Viney), gifted a high-profile coach...

North Melbourne are currently trying their best to imitate the Melbourne FC model. If, in a few years time, the Kangaroos have an almighty list that are winning premierships for fun, I will be similarly reserved in my praise for their achievements.

Bingo.

[GVGjr]

Re: Melbourne Watch 2023

So Pert and Goodwiin fronted SEN and talked about some of the troubles the club has faced mainly Oliver and Smith and even with May.
Pert said it was the most professional and strong culture he's been associated with in his 40 year AFL career.

It's a ballsy move to front the media but I sensed Pert and Goodwin were well scripted to answer the questions before they were asked.

Goodwin reconfirmed he doesn't take drugs and he's sick of the way this has constantly been speculated on.

Goodwin also said he has not spoken to Joel Smith since news of his positive test was released which seems strange to me if the professional culture is as strong as they were trying to sell.

[Grantysghost]

Re: Melbourne Watch 2023

So Pert and Goodwiin fronted SEN and talked about some of the troubles the club has faced mainly Oliver and Smith and even with May.
Pert said it was the most professional and strong culture he's been associated with in his 40 year AFL career.

It's a ballsy move to front the media but I sensed Pert and Goodwin were well scripted to answer the questions before they were asked.

Goodwin reconfirmed he doesn't take drugs and he's sick of the way this has constantly been speculated on.

Goodwin also said he has not spoken to Joel Smith since news of his positive test was released which seems strange to me if the professional culture is as strong as they were trying to sell.

Pert is the ultimate baller. Complete gamer.

Smart move getting out on the front foot.

Goodwin was at the Crows and Dons during dubious times, then had a president sacked who wanted to call it out.

You don't have to be Einstein.

[Twodogs]

Re: Melbourne Watch 2023

I see Oliver is saying he suffers from ADHD and it was an adverse reaction to the medication that caused him to fall over the night he ended up at Footscray Hospital.

ADHD is a real bastard and I wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy. But I'm medicated for ADHD too and I've never passed out from the effects.

[Grantysghost]

Re: Melbourne Watch 2023

I see Oliver is saying he suffers from ADHD and it was an adverse reaction to the medication that caused him to fall over the night he ended up at Footscray Hospital.

ADHD is a real bastard and I wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy. But I'm medicated for ADHD too and I've never passed out from the effects.

Would be a pretty low play to blame that if it wasn't true. Seems like something Melbourne would do.

[Twodogs]

Re: Melbourne Watch 2023

Would be a pretty low play to blame that if it wasn't true. Seems like something Melbourne would do.

I have no doubt that Oliver probably does suffer from ADHD. His decision making and the problems he has all point to it, but the "my medication made me fall over and hit my head" story doesn't add up to me.

[EasternWest]

Re: Melbourne Watch 2023

I have no doubt that Oliver probably does suffer from ADHD. His decision making and the problems he has all point to it, but the "my medication made me fall over and hit my head" story doesn't add up to me.

Yeah it stinks.

Like, I hope he's alright and if he has a problem he gets proper care, but it's not helpful to demonise actual medication like that.

[Grantysghost]

Re: Melbourne Watch 2023

I have no doubt that Oliver probably does suffer from ADHD. His decision making and the problems he has all point to it, but the "my medication made me fall over and hit my head" story doesn't add up to me.

It does make sufferers search for balance from experience.
Red Bull or Vodka or both?