Kelli underwood

[Ghost Dog]

Re: Kelli underwood

If she really wants to be a commentator then she will take it as feedback, change her style a bit and be back into it. as noted, at least she gets our player's names right on a regular basis. All she would have to do, IMO is not lay it on so thick - just speak in a normal tone.

Richo is one of my favourite commentators - love his dry humour and some good insights.

[Throughandthrough]

Re: Kelli underwood

Cos there are are plenty of male commentators that are worse that keep there job and are as analyzed like her.

Nsme names?

As I said above, she is boring to the nth degree.

[Twodogs]

Re: Kelli underwood

Nsme names?

Bennett
Healy
Taylor
Russell-did he mention that Craig Bradley is a mate of his?


That's off the top of my head without hearing a football match being called for over four months. If it were mid season I coul easily add another half a dozen names without thinking too hard.

[azabob]

Re: Kelli underwood

Nsme names?

As I said above, she is boring to the nth degree.

I'd prefer her to Andrew Maher, Brian Taylor, Steve Quartermain, anyone from SEN (Anthony Hudson goes ok).

By far the best broadcaster of AFL is ABC 774. The team is near perfect (Drew Morphett is the exception) with their knowledge and ability to communicate what is going on.

Each person knows and understands their role and not too many egos in the ABC team.

[Bornadog]

Re: Kelli underwood

I'd prefer her to Andrew Maher, Brian Taylor, Steve Quartermain, anyone from SEN (Anthony Hudson goes ok).

By far the best broadcaster of AFL is ABC 774. The team is near perfect (Drew Morphett is the exception) with their knowledge and ability to communicate what is going on.

Each person knows and understands their role and not too many egos in the ABC team.

Spot on, although I do like Drew as a caller.

[Throughandthrough]

Re: Kelli underwood

I'd prefer her to Andrew Maher, Brian Taylor, Steve Quartermain, anyone from SEN (Anthony Hudson goes ok).

By far the best broadcaster of AFL is ABC 774. The team is near perfect (Drew Morphett is the exception) with their knowledge and ability to communicate what is going on.

Each person knows and understands their role and not too many egos in the ABC team.

Don't start me on Drew Morphett!

But he has mellowed over the last decade and is now bearable. He used to shockingly barrack for his favourite players (Ablett, Carey, etc) and call their names only when the ball is in their area

and Ablett ! ABBBLEEETTTT!!! Flies for a SCREAMER. But no, it's been marked in front of him by the Hawthorn defender who plays on and.....

[LostDoggy]

Re: Kelli underwood

Nsme names?

As I said above, she is boring to the nth degree.

Hunt, walls , schwartz, Roberts, blight, macaveny, Watson , brayshaw are all as bad if not worse. That was my Quick list

[chef]

Re: Kelli underwood

Nsme names?

As I said above, she is boring to the nth degree.

Cometti
Brayshaw
Walls
Bruce
Jakovich
Pickering
Watson
Richardson
Smith
Not all are commentators(some are special comments), but they all offer less than Underwood IMO.

[Remi Moses]

Re: Kelli underwood

I'd prefer her to Andrew Maher, Brian Taylor, Steve Quartermain, anyone from SEN (Anthony Hudson goes ok).

By far the best broadcaster of AFL is ABC 774. The team is near perfect (Drew Morphett is the exception) with their knowledge and ability to communicate what is going on.

Each person knows and understands their role and not too many egos in the ABC team.

I like the ABC team as well.
Gerard Whately is excellent,Drew's okay.
Stan Alves and Mark Maclure are very good in expert comments
Dan Lonergan I enjoy (good dog man)
The other stations feel to me a mixture of massive egos who get in each others way(hello SEN AW and bloke FM)

[Throughandthrough]

Re: Kelli underwood

Looking at the above, I think if we listed every tv commentator and then crossed off everyone who someone had mentioned, then Kelli Underwood would be the only one left!

[LostDoggy]

Re: Kelli underwood

Looking at the above, I think if we listed every tv commentator and then crossed off everyone who someone had mentioned, then Kelli Underwood would be the only one left!

No idea what you are trying to say or prove there. Crossed off? Who crossed them off?

[AndrewP6]

Re: Kelli underwood

No idea what you are trying to say or prove there. Crossed off? Who crossed them off?

I think T&T is saying that people appear to hate every single one of the commentators, leaving only Kelli. Or something.

[Throughandthrough]

Re: Kelli underwood

yeah its not that hard. I cbf scrolling above bit theres about fifteen commentators that various people say that Kelli Underwood is better then.

[chef]

Re: Kelli underwood

I think T&T is saying that people appear to hate every single one of the commentators, leaving only Kelli. Or something.

Not everyone. Just that there's a few more that are worse and deserved to get sacked before Kelly.