Tom Liberatore

[GVGjr]

Re: Tom Liberatore

Perfect for who? There is no "perfect age", everybody is different.

There is a tendency in football to judge players by their age, height, speed or experience etc and in this instance about becoming a parent
In most instances it's nearly always one of those classic 'time will tell' scenario's.

I seem to recall that Stringer was seen by many as a mature type because he became a parent at something like 19 and now some might find Liberatore at 27 as being a bit young

You're 100% spot on, there is no real perfect age and most people are different

[Bornadog]

Re: Tom Liberatore

There is a tendency in football to judge players by their age, height, speed or experience etc and in this instance about becoming a parent
In most instances it's nearly always one of those classic 'time will tell' scenario's.

I seem to recall that Stringer was seen by many as a mature type because he became a parent at something like 19 and now some might find Liberatore at 27 as being a bit young

You're 100% spot on, there is no real perfect age and most people are different

He is only young due to the average in society now, nothing wrong with having a child at his age in life, each to their own

[GVGjr]

Re: Tom Liberatore

He is only young due to the average in society now, nothing wrong with having a child at his age in life, each to their own

But his age was called out before you knew what the average was and only was done after GD queried the reference to his age.
I think given his career including his attitude and approach to life, Liberatore has frequently proven to be anything but average.
It's likely that time will tell if the average is relevant.

[AshMac]

Re: Tom Liberatore

He's always seemed to be a player that has responded very well to challenges and hopefully this might be the spur to really get stuck into it this year. I remain very hopeful that despite his injury setbacks we will see a very good version of Tom Liberatore on the park this year

If he can play 20 games this year, then to date we are getting excited about the wrong players. The potential impact Libba can bring to the team would be the greatest of our list IMO - spiritually and physically.

I’ll remain optimistic and hopeful that we e see the Libba we’ve all been waiting 3 years for back again.

[Mofra]

Re: Tom Liberatore

If he can play 20 games this year, then to date we are getting excited about the wrong players. The potential impact Libba can bring to the team would be the greatest of our list IMO - spiritually and physically.

I’ll remain optimistic and hopeful that we e see the Libba we’ve all been waiting 3 years for back again.

Where does that leave our midfield rotations?
One track watcher said Bailey Smith has been playing wing - he can do that. How do we rotate Bont, Macrae and Dunkley through the middle? Bont and Macrae can play outside, Dunks less so. Libba is a beautiful left foot kick but his strength is winning the ball and tackling so he'd be the 'extracter' when he's in there.

Will he be happy to start on the bench as an 'impact' player and have the odd stint forward as a defensive forward? We do tend to play a 6th mid as a forward but Libba isn't that great at it.

[The Pie Man]

Re: Tom Liberatore

Where does that leave our midfield rotations?
One track watcher said Bailey Smith has been playing wing - he can do that. How do we rotate Bont, Macrae and Dunkley through the middle? Bont and Macrae can play outside, Dunks less so. Libba is a beautiful left foot kick but his strength is winning the ball and tackling so he'd be the 'extracter' when he's in there.

Will he be happy to start on the bench as an 'impact' player and have the odd stint forward as a defensive forward? We do tend to play a 6th mid as a forward but Libba isn't that great at it.

Smith on a wing could be a beautiful thing. Any clues on his tank (other than looking ripping fit)?

[Sedat]

Re: Tom Liberatore

We are 4-0 in finals with Libba in the team and 0-2 in finals without him. When fully fit, Libba only makes us stronger.

[mjp]

Re: Tom Liberatore

But his age was called out before you knew what the average was and only was done after GD queried the reference to his age.
I think given his career including his attitude and approach to life, Liberatore has frequently proven to be anything but average.
It's likely that time will tell if the average is relevant.

JJ had a child last year and (happy to be corrected) his age wasn’t mentioned.

He is the same age as Tom.

[GVGjr]

Re: Tom Liberatore

JJ had a child last year and (happy to be corrected) his age wasn’t mentioned.

He is the same age as Tom.

Good point.

[Bornadog]

Re: Tom Liberatore

JJ had a child last year and (happy to be corrected) his age wasn’t mentioned.

He is the same age as Tom.

Good point.

But his age was called out before you knew what the average was and only was done after GD queried the reference to his age.

I am not sure why a big deal is being made. All I said was I was surprised at his age he is a father. Also, what you are saying GVGjr is incorrect. I was going on experience. My daughter is 26 and none of her friends are married or with kids.

It is a known fact people are leaving marriage and birth to their 30s now. I followed up with the average, to prove a point, but as I said who cares, it is up to individuals.

Why go on about it.

[GVGjr]

Re: Tom Liberatore

I am not sure why a big deal is being made. All I said was I was surprised at his age he is a father. Also, what you are saying GVGjr is incorrect. I was going on experience. My daughter is 26 and none of her friends are married or with kids.

It is a known fact people are leaving marriage and birth to their 30s now. I followed up with the average, to prove a point, but as I said who cares, it is up to individuals.

Why go on about it.

You've provided the clarity and thanks for that.
The point I'm making is from what I have seen with Liberatore over the years he strikes me as a unique type not one likely to be in the 'averages'.

[Bornadog]

Re: Tom Liberatore

You've provided the clarity and thanks for that.
The point I'm making is from what I have seen with Liberatore over the years he strikes me as a unique type not one likely to be in the 'averages'.

That I agree with for sure. I hope he has a good season, because he will be invaluable if fit and firing and best 22 as far as I am concerned.

[AshMac]

Re: Tom Liberatore

Where does that leave our midfield rotations?
One track watcher said Bailey Smith has been playing wing - he can do that. How do we rotate Bont, Macrae and Dunkley through the middle? Bont and Macrae can play outside, Dunks less so. Libba is a beautiful left foot kick but his strength is winning the ball and tackling so he'd be the 'extracter' when he's in there.

Will he be happy to start on the bench as an 'impact' player and have the odd stint forward as a defensive forward? We do tend to play a 6th mid as a forward but Libba isn't that great at it.

I can see Libba resting in the forward line more than Dunkley - but yeh it’s force one out. Like the idea of bailey smith on a wing assumed given his age it’s be him

[Twodogs]

Re: Tom Liberatore

There's a big difference between having a child as a result of a long term relationship (like Tom) and just knocking up the first girl you get to do it with( like a lot of kids did in my day).

Age has little to do with how good a parent you are. The mother of my kids is 15 years younger than me and she is a terrific parent.

[Bornadog]

Re: Tom Liberatore