Stringer Trade Worth

[chef]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Don't have to accept anything. Essendon's priorities seem to be Saad and Smith ahead of jake .
Big wake up call, and let's see what transpires

Maybe they think we'll cave.

[Remi Moses]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

To me theres no coming back for Jake, he'll end up being traded but unfortunately it won't be a great deal for us.

You've got that opinion listening to the constant incessant media noise on Stringer. I'd listen to what Bevo said before I'd listen to the drivel Eminating from the media. My ears are hurting from the many opinions now in football

[SonofScray]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

The thing is I think this is player driven as well so not sure how forgiving they will be..don't know it's pretty yucky all round

All the commentary I've seen from the players is that if Jake stayed, they'd welcome him back and support him to play his best football as part of the group. Morris etc all know his value when straight and well prepared and have said as much. Bevo says it isn't irretrievable. Even if the players are demanding more from him, I think it is on the coaching group and footy GM to make this work, Jake too. If he stays, in some ways it is back in jake's court to have a strong contract year and demonstrate his worth and force the trade scenario. Who knows what happens there tough? Ryan O'Keefe was shopped around and wanted to walk when that fell through, stayed on and won a flag at Sydney.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

All the commentary I've seen from the players is that if Jake stayed, they'd welcome him back and support him to play his best football as part of the group. Morris etc all know his value when straight and well prepared and have said as much. Bevo says it isn't irretrievable. Even if the players are demanding more from him, I think it is on the coaching group and footy GM to make this work, Jake too. If he stays, in some ways it is back in jake's court to have a strong contract year and demonstrate his worth and force the trade scenario. Who knows what happens there tough? Ryan O'Keefe was shopped around and wanted to walk when that fell through, stayed on and won a flag at Sydney.

Good call on R'oK. He was all but at Hawthorn until Pelchan screwed him over. Had a brilliant career after.

We need Connors to awaken any other clubs looking for a player like Jake.

[chef]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

You've got that opinion listening to the constant incessant media noise on Stringer. I'd listen to what Bevo said before I'd listen to the drivel Eminating from the media. My ears are hurting from the many opinions now in football

Nah mate, my opinion isnt based on what either side are saying to the media. More based on what Jake did and who he did it with, doubt he'd have much respect left at the club and he'll get moved on for whatever we end up getting. Thats just how i see it.

[boydogs]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Stevo reckons we may have to accept picks 24 and 29. Haha gee we've painted ourselves into a corner on this one.

Do you rate the AFL's draft value index? Because those two picks together are valued at better than pick 10

[Rocket Science]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Maybe they think we'll cave.

Show of hands ... who thinks we'll cave?

Rather, who's concerned we'll cave?

*raises hand*

[The Bulldogs Bite]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Show of hands ... who thinks we'll cave?

Rather, who's concerned we'll cave?

*raises hand*

I’m merely hoping we show some spine but I’m not confident.

A week to go.

[Ghost Dog]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

*not raising hand*
We won't cave.
If I had a son who was in the same boat, with this ridiculous carry on of women and gambling, near Bevo is where I would want him to be.

[chef]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Do you rate the AFL's draft value index? Because those two picks together are valued at better than pick 10

Its not a great deal. I guess the only comfort is Dal has a pretty good strike rate at picking good kids.

[chef]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Show of hands ... who thinks we'll cave?

Rather, who's concerned we'll cave?

*raises hand*

Im glad Gordons got involved. Jmac doesnt instill me with confidence.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Do you rate the AFL's draft value index? Because those two picks together are valued at better than pick 10

But it's what you do with them in a DVI context. I reckon Brisbane with Ballenden is the best bet if it's a straight draft points:

Dogs: 12, 18 & 19 (maybe a player who wants out, of not huge value)
Lions: 9, 24, 27, 29 (400 net points)

That doesn't scream do the Stringer trade.

[GVGjr]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Do you rate the AFL's draft value index? Because those two picks together are valued at better than pick 10

It's an offer worth considering. Perhaps we could look at one of them being next years pick

We potentially have 6 players going out and we have Trengove (confirmed) and Crozier (likely) so we could use 4 picks all before pick 30. If Campbell is traded then we have another spot.

[kruder]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Wish trade fortnight was over already, when you're invested in it yet so far from the action its not easy to enjoy! Well done to Melbourne and Adelaide even after a little bad blood they got down to work and got the deal done.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

It's an offer worth considering. Perhaps we could look at one of them being next years pick

We potentially have 6 players going out and we have Trengove (confirmed) and Crozier (likely) so we could use 4 picks all before pick 30. If Campbell is traded then we have another spot.

So go backwards two trade periods in a row. I can't support the two second rounder deal.