Stringer Trade Worth

[boydogs]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Does anyone have some suggestions on what might be a doable trade with the Cats?

They have literally one player worth as much as Stringer, and they just traded him in. Selwood & Hawkins are too old. They would have to find a club willing to upgrade their first rounder for a couple of players e.g. 20, Menzel & Blicavs to St Kilda for 8

[Remi Moses]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Geelong aren't rebuilding , so you'd assume it won't be an early pick again next season .

[GVGjr]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Whilst I see the value in trading for a Geelong first rounder in the following year's draft and throwing in a sweetener this year, it'ss going to be a hard sell for the broader Bulldog supporter base to swallow without going rabid.

But we might have to suck it up and look at the future. In 12 months we've gone from a position of strength with a playing list to one with a quite a few holes in it so that's most likely not a quick fix. Agree that it will take a bit of spin to sell this to possibly an impatient fan base but we may have to play a longer game. Potentially having 2 x 1st round picks in what is regarded as a super-draft is a far easier sell in another 12 months.

[GVGjr]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Geelong aren't rebuilding , so you'd assume it won't be an early pick again next season .

They could slip back though and it's a stronger draft. We would need something to sweeten the offer.

[Yankee Hotel Foxtrot]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

They could slip back though and it's a stronger draft. We would need something to sweeten the offer.

Way too big a risk on accepting their 1st next year on a hope that they 'might slip'. They don't and the addition of Ablett and Stringer nets them another top 4 finish...and we get a pick in the range of 15-18.
That doesn't sit well.

[Remi Moses]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Way to big a risk on accepting their 1st next year on a hope that they 'might slip'. They don't and the addition of Ablett and Stringer nets them another top 4 finish...and we get a pick in the range of 15-18.
That doesn't sit well.

I don't think they'll slip either , and recruiting Ablett at 34 shows they still think they're in the window .

[Yankee Hotel Foxtrot]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

I don't think they'll slip either , and recruiting Ablett at 34 shows they still think they're in the window .

Yep. It would be just a gamble. If Jake is going then we need something tangible in return, if not commensurate in value then at least not a pure gamble.
I know Gary was indicating Geelong would need to throw something else in, but to be honest I'm not sure any 'sweetener' would not wind up tasting bitter should Geelong's 2018 1st round pick end up pick 15-18. Strong draft or not.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Yep. It would be just a gamble. If Jake is going then we need something tangible in return, if not commensurate in value then at least not a pure gamble.
I know Gary was indicating Geelong would need to throw something else in, but to be honest I'm not sure any 'sweetener' would not wind up tasting bitter should Geelong's 2018 1st round pick end up pick 15-18. Strong draft or not.

Handing Hawthorn 3 premierships, a Brian a Norm Smith, I'm not inclined to give another team a chance at a flag or three.

I'm ok with factoring in their pick as 16 next year, in taking on the risk (if it's 18 ah well, if it's 10 it's our bonus). So that would leave them well short, unless they give us a player that we really, really want. That's assuming they can future trade a first rounder again.

[Yankee Hotel Foxtrot]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Handing Hawthorn 3 premierships, a Brian a Norm Smith, I'm not inclined to give another team a chance at a flag or three.

I'm ok with factoring in their pick as 16 next year, in taking on the risk (if it's 18 ah well, if it's 10 it's our bonus). So that would leave them well short, unless they give us a player that we really, really want. That's assuming they can future trade a first rounder again.

And that's what I mean. The only way next year's 1st round pick works for me is if its secondary..and i don't think Geelong are wanting to part with something that equates to what we'd want in that regard.
They're more likely to float someone like a Lang or Parfitt...thanks....forget it...

[Happy Days]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

So he's met with Essendon, and Landsberger is reporting that 11 alone won't get it done, which warms my heart.

I'd think long and hard about 11 and Francis, but I can't tell if he's truly had a bad run with injuries or he's just an unfit fat dude who won't shape up.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

And that's what I mean. The only way next year's 1st round pick works for me is if its secondary..and i don't think Geelong are wanting to part with something that equates to what we'd want in that regard.
They're more likely to float someone like a Lang or Parfitt...thanks....forget it...

That's the hard part. They've been on trading and may not be able to. Their list is horrible for talent they can trade with. I've said Cockatoo is about the only one I'd support us going after, but he needs a thorough medical with those hamstrings of his. They're in not position to trade for Jake Stringer. The best thing the footy media to do us admit that, and then work out which clubs might be able to actually do a deal.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

So he's met with Essendon, and Landsberger is reporting that 11 alone won't get it done, which warms my heart.

I'd think long and hard about 11 and Francis, but I can't tell if he's truly had a bad run with injuries or he's just an unfit fat dude who won't shape up.

Like. I honestly thought he was just a fat VFL top up. I couldn't believe that was Francis of drafting fame. We need some run or forward picket type, maybe Fantasia as the extra scoop?

[Dry Rot]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

So he's met with Essendon, and Landsberger is reporting that 11 alone won't get it done, which warms my heart.

I'd think long and hard about 11 and Francis, but I can't tell if he's truly had a bad run with injuries or he's just an unfit fat dude who won't shape up.

Unfit fat dude.

I wonder if we could get Stewart?

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Jordan Ridley drafted last year by Essendon just after Tim Eniglish (22) sounds a Bevo type:

A tall runner from the Oakleigh Chargers who is versatile enough to play in almost any position and can be moved around the field seemingly without any disruption to his play. Highly skilled, he won the kicking test at the NAB AFL Draft Combine, after averaging 19 disposals in the TAC Cup.

Former AFL recruiter Gary Buckenara says:

Ridley will be of interest to clubs because he’s a flexible prospect. At 192cm he can play in a number of positions whether it be down back, up forward or in the midfield, but probably plays his best footy as a defender. He’s a hard worker.

Oakleigh Chargers Talent Manager Craig Notman told Inside Football:

He has a great set of hands and is a real confidence player, a terrific character and a hard worker. He will get the best out of himself wherever he plays. Playing down back actually freed him up a bit and showed he has some gears. He went inside a couple of times and was effective so he could turn into that bigger bodied mid.

[GVGjr]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

So he's met with Essendon, and Landsberger is reporting that 11 alone won't get it done, which warms my heart.

I'd think long and hard about 11 and Francis, but I can't tell if he's truly had a bad run with injuries or he's just an unfit fat dude who won't shape up.

Essendon believe 11 is too much, and want something coming back the other way
We want more than pick 11.