Rating the 2022 Trade Period - After 7.30pm Wednesday Night

[Grantysghost]

Re: Rating the 2022 Trade Period - After 7.30pm Wednesday Night

Trade targets have been James Jordon (22yo), Brynn Teakle (23yo) and Nick Coffield (22yo). We're also trying to get pick 4 to access an elite young player, as well as likely securing Croft. I think that's enough focus on the future?

I think we're balancing it well. I don't think we are at a point where the list should be completely gutted. If we can replace guys like Roarke, Crozier, Bruce with 22/23yo I think that's a net win.

What do you think Coffield is worth on the open market JD?

Former top 10 pick, I get the feeling the Aints might be stupidly wanting overs.

[Bornadog]

Re: Rating the 2022 Trade Period - After 7.30pm Wednesday Night

Trade targets have been James Jordon (22yo), Brynn Teakle (23yo) and Nick Coffield (22yo). We're also trying to get pick 4 to access an elite young player, as well as likely securing Croft. I think that's enough focus on the future?

I think we're balancing it well. I don't think we are at a point where the list should be completely gutted. If we can replace guys like Roarke, Crozier, Bruce with 22/23yo I think that's a net win.

All young players and known quantities unlike some 4th or 5th round 18 year olds

[Bulldog4life]

Re: Rating the 2022 Trade Period - After 7.30pm Wednesday Night

I understand the sentiment. I guess there's a bit of being a good citizen involved too and not having a reputation of treating players like commodities, rather like people.
Flipside, he was all #teamdunks with his choice of clubs. As many wiser have said prior to me leaving isn't the concern as much as the club he chose.

For that reason it would irk me if he won one up there, however it's a minor irk and he's a Lions player now so pffft.
I just hope we handled his exit in an optimal fashion (didn't have levers we didn't pull after he went) for the club.
There was no way the Lions were going to be able to pay what we wanted. Their future first, could've been anything (see Freo).

In future we need to trade prior to contract expiry if we don't get a solid commitment (except Bont).

There is a WOOFER who is a keen Lion supporter. Now who is that?

[azabob]

Re: Rating the 2022 Trade Period - After 7.30pm Wednesday Night

There is a WOOFER who is a keen Lion supporter. Now who is that?

I know Chef and I are Lions supporters this week, but do we have a legit Lions supporter among us?

[Bulldog4life]

Re: Rating the 2022 Trade Period - After 7.30pm Wednesday Night

I know Chef and I are Lions supporters this week, but do we have a legit Lions supporter among us?

Yes but he will have to come forward himself.

[Grantysghost]

Re: Rating the 2022 Trade Period - After 7.30pm Wednesday Night

Yes but he will have to come forward himself.

I think i've been tagged as such : but it's all lies ...LIES I TELL YA.

Go Lions.

[Eastdog]

Re: Rating the 2022 Trade Period - After 7.30pm Wednesday Night

Looking back now we certainly got duded in that trade period and I'm keen to see if we can rectify it this time round.

Be really good if could improve our draft hand and get in someone in of quality who will be a huge contributor to the team.

Lobb had a great 2022 but was suspect in 2023. As one woofer said I would have loved players like Bedford, Hill and Acres.

[Axe Man]

Re: Rating the 2022 Trade Period - After 7.30pm Wednesday Night

I think i've been tagged as such : but it's all lies ...LIES I TELL YA.

Go Lions.

GG at 2:30pm this Saturday:

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Rating the 2022 Trade Period - After 7.30pm Wednesday Night

Dunkley Trade Official:

Brisbane got Dunkley
Dogs got Clarke & 1/3 of Pick 5 along with 1/3 of the three third rounders (draft point deficit in the pick swap and two fourths we may/probably won?t use.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Rating the 2022 Trade Period - After 7.30pm Wednesday Night

If Gresham was end of 1st:

Lobb is Pick 33 this year but *could* be around 38 after bids (on top of 30 last year, pushed out to 33 after bids)
Hunter gets us Pick 57


Hunter looks a little worse
Lobb at 33 & 38 (after bids) looks a little better if he re finds form

Also we got Pick 39 or 40 for our third & the Hunter pick which offsets this years pick for Lobb. So you could argue loosely that the real cost for Lobb is 33 last year and two thirds this year. If you like that argument, then the cost of Lobb isn’t that high.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Rating the 2022 Trade Period - After 7.30pm Wednesday Night

So we can do it properly now:

I can’t see any official record of a live trade with Sydney, so it’s based off that not happening.

Lobb: Picks 33 & 37 after bids (*notionally end of R2 & start of R3 picks)
Hunter (after being packaged into Pick 40 and then unpackaged: Freijah (& Coffield with the F3 that was in that unpackaging 40)
Schache: Pick deleted/nothing

Dunkley: Clarke, 1/3 Sanders, 1/3 Croft, 1/3 of the F3, Lach Smith, AOD (4th we demanded tied to Geelong), Freijah (by packaging up the two F3’s into the F2 which was unpackaged to slightly better picks to get part of Croft, and also Freijah & Coffield)

Twomey sees it the way I see it in an article this morning. The Dunkley pick went for Points/Picks. So the trade is now Pick 11 & F1 for Pick 6 & F3 plus getting Freijah.

(Huge salary cap relief)


So it’s that old chestnut about one good player in Dunkley. Or trading them out and using that trade in a way to acquire with creativity Sanders, Clarke, Croft, Freijah, Smith, AOD & Coffield - who all can be traced to some part of the sprawling Dunkley deal.

[bulldogsthru&thru]

Re: Rating the 2022 Trade Period - After 7.30pm Wednesday Night

I think Sanders alone might make the trade look alright. No pressure kid.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Rating the 2022 Trade Period - After 7.30pm Wednesday Night

In:

Liam Jones
Rory Lobb

Pick 21 (Clarke Delisted)
Future 1st (Lions, traded with two other firsts for Sanders)
Future 2nd (Lions, split for draft points)
Future 4th (Geelong - used on AOD, Retired)



Out:

Cordy
Schache
Hunter (and we pay part of his salary for two years) & the F3 went to Lions
Dunkley
Pick 30
Future Second (ours)
Future Third (ours)
Future Third (Dees)

Charlie Clarke
Aiden O?Driscoll



Dunkley: Some (very few) points for Croft hardly worth mentioning - split in the Coffield trade with the F4 essentially for Coff. No games from AOD. 1/2 a game from Clarke. 1/3 of Sanders deal including 1/3 points for Croft. That is the return now.

[jazzadogs]

Re: Rating the 2022 Trade Period - After 7.30pm Wednesday Night

Future 1st (Lions, traded with two other firsts for Sanders) - 2023 pick 23, GC, Riley Hardeman

Pick 30 2022 - Freo, Hugh Davies

Future Second (ours) - pick 37 2023 - Tew Jiath
Future Third (ours) - absorbed for points
Future Third (Dees) - pick 48 2023 - Tom Anastasopolous

Not much of quality or concern that we missed out on...

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Rating the 2022 Trade Period - After 7.30pm Wednesday Night

Future 1st (Lions, traded with two other firsts for Sanders) - 2023 pick 23, GC, Riley Hardeman

Pick 30 2022 - Freo, Hugh Davies

Future Second (ours) - pick 37 2023 - Tew Jiath
Future Third (ours) - absorbed for points
Future Third (Dees) - pick 48 2023 - Tom Anastasopolous

Not much of quality or concern that we missed out on...

Schache & Hunter no longer playing either. Cordy not doing a great deal to impress at St Kilda. The list of ins and outs is a bit of a mess. Thank God Lobb worked out in defence or he could be elsewhere now too.