Always Right Match Committee Round 8 vs GWS

[Ozza]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 8 vs GWS

This is a good suggestion and has a bit of forward planning to it.
The question for many would be how can we drop a player in good form for someone in questionable form. I get that Gards is more capable of playing on key forwards but it can't be an easy decision.

Bit of a stretch for me to consider O'Brien in good form.
Gardner was probably best on ground in the VFL on the weekend - and has certainly done his time coming back through the VFL since the last weekend in March.

[Stevo]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 8 vs GWS

Bit of a stretch for me to consider O'Brien in good form.
Gardner was probably best on ground in the VFL on the weekend - and has certainly done his time coming back through the VFL since the last weekend in March.

Bit harsh there Ozza. I want Gardner in the side but TOB has done more than enough to hold his spot.

[Bornadog]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 8 vs GWS

Libba new look, ready for Saturday

[GVGjr]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 8 vs GWS

Missing his mo.

[kruder]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 8 vs GWS

Missing his mo.

Im not sure he is thinking straight

[Bumper Bulldogs]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 8 vs GWS

Libba new look, ready for Saturday

Still can identify him by the Tattoos

[Bulldog Joe]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 8 vs GWS

Still can identify him by the Tattoos

Libba is identified by being Libba

[D Mitchell]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 8 vs GWS

Still can identify him by the Tattoos

Tattoos ? I looked at the boots, Yes, Bob Murphy. Hang on.....

[Rocco Jones]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 8 vs GWS

With players at level of Gardy, Keath and TOB, I believe it's largely the duo that fits in best with Jones. TOB might be the third 'best' individual player but I think he fits best due to his foot skills and 1:1 defending less of a priority in 3rd tall role. I'd prefer not to play Keath and Gardy alongside Jones as all are a worry with the ball in hand. I have Gardner over Keath atm.

[1eyedog]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 8 vs GWS

Jones > Gardner > TOB.

[Rocco Jones]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 8 vs GWS

Jones > Gardner > TOB.

I'd play those three too. Not about TOB being a better player than Keath. I probably think Keath is a 'better player' but TOB fits being alongside Jones + Gardner better.

[Axe Man]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 8 vs GWS

Bruce could be back in 2 or 3 weeks as well. Could be a (good) headache for the match committee if all 5 KPDs are fit at once.

[Grantysghost]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 8 vs GWS

With players at level of Gardy, Keath and TOB, I believe it's largely the duo that fits in best with Jones. TOB might be the third 'best' individual player but I think he fits best due to his foot skills and 1:1 defending less of a priority in 3rd tall role. I'd prefer not to play Keath and Gardy alongside Jones as all are a worry with the ball in hand. I have Gardner over Keath atm.

Agree - not sure the MC will though. Keath has been solid I guess; is there really that much difference between the two?

I can't see Keath losing his spot any time soon. Which means I can't really see Gardner coming in any time soon.

When we had all available the preferred trio, irrespective of match-ups was Bruce, Jones, Keath.

Personally I would've thought Gardy was more like for like to replace Bruce, so I really don't know why they'd change their position now.

[Axe Man]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 8 vs GWS

Agree - not sure the MC will though. Keath has been solid I guess; is there really that much difference between the two?

I can't see Keath losing his spot any time soon. Which means I can't really see Gardner coming in any time soon.

When we had all available the preferred trio, irrespective of match-ups was Bruce, Jones, Keath.

Personally I would've thought Gardy was more like for like to replace Bruce, so I really don't know why they'd change their position now.

We haven't had all available though. Gardner has taken some time to get back up to speed and now is probably the first time he is ready to return to the senior side. TOB was also injured and obviously Bruce more recently. We still don't know the match committees' preferred 3 and that can be a quickly changeable position in any case.

[Grantysghost]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 8 vs GWS

We haven't had all available though. Gardner has taken some time to get back up to speed and now is probably the first time he is ready to return to the senior side. TOB was also injured and obviously Bruce more recently. We still don't know the match committees' preferred 3 and that can be a quickly changeable position in any case.

You make a fine point sir.