Welcome to the Kennel - Nick Coffield

[bulldogsthru&thru]

Re: Nick Coffield nominates Bulldogs

We'll just pick him up in the psd then.

[WBFC4FFC]

Re: Nick Coffield nominates Bulldogs

We'll just pick him up in the psd then.

Posturing.

TheSaints are offering an ordinary contract v. the Bulldogs, yet all of a sudden they bring out he's finished in the Top 5 in the B&F!

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Nick Coffield nominates Bulldogs

Looking at it, if 46 is part of the deal for Grundy.
46 to Aints for Billings (with salary picked up)
46 & 56 with Coffield to dogs for 40, 69 & 72

Aints offer 40 (2nd round) and a slight upgrade (35 for 46) for Henry. If there?s only 55-60 picks in the draft they upgrade into the second round and the slight downgrade makes no difference.


????


Or if Freo want 35, 40 & 69 for Henry and St Kilda happy to get back 46 & 59:

Freo: 35, 40 & 69 (very possibly packaged up to a pick from GCS: either 22, 24, 27 or 28 after selling 10 to Dees/North/Crows)
Aints: Henry, 59 & 72 (paying Coffield, 35 & 56)
Dogs: 46 & 56 with Coffield (paying 40, 69 & 72)

Dogs net 127 draft points and get Coffield
Freo possibly trade into the mid 20’s - good price for Henry
Aints turn Coffield, a late 2nd into Henry and a fourth rounder

Makes sense to me.

[GVGjr]

Re: Nick Coffield nominates Bulldogs

SOS seems like posturing here around Dow vs Coffield trade values. This probably means he would want similar or better for Coffield than he'd pay for Dow:

Zero Hanger

SOS drafted Dow, he didn't draft Coffield and that was the same draft.

[Axe Man]

Re: Nick Coffield nominates Bulldogs

SOS seems like posturing here around Dow vs Coffield trade values. This probably means he would want similar or better for Coffield than he'd pay for Dow:

Zero Hanger

And Bob Skilton won three Brownlows but I'm not giving up more than a third round pick for him since he's 84.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Nick Coffield nominates Bulldogs

Updated: works well now:

Freo: 35, 39 & 68 > GCS Pick 23
Aints: Henry, 59 & 71 (paying Coffield, 35 & 55)
Dogs: 45 & 55 with Coffield (paying 39, 68 & 71)

Dogs net 156 draft points and get Coffield
GCS net 242 Draft points more
Freo get Pick 23 for Henry
Aints turn Coffield & a late 2nd into Henry and a fourth rounder

Win-Win-Win-Win


Updated: Covers Croft at 11 and points for Lual if needed with Sweet for 48 as reported is likely to happen. Happy to give Port pick 73 if needed. Then it’s Pick 5 (Watson?), Croft, Lual (?) and maybe a late re-draft like Bedendo with rookie upgrade/s (Scott at least) plus Harmes & Coffield as our trade/draft. Two rookie draft picks, an SSP selection and MSD pick.

[GVGjr]

Re: Nick Coffield nominates Bulldogs

Brilliant BT,

[hujsh]

Re: Nick Coffield nominates Bulldogs

Updated: works well now:

Freo: 35, 39 & 68 > GCS Pick 23
Aints: Henry, 59 & 71 (paying Coffield, 35 & 55)
Dogs: 45 & 55 with Coffield (paying 39, 68 & 71)

Dogs net 156 draft points and get Coffield
GCS net 242 Draft points more
Freo get Pick 23 for Henry
Aints turn Coffield & a late 2nd into Henry and a fourth rounder

Win-Win-Win-Win

I like it, the only issue being if Saints consider that fair. I think they should but who knows

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Nick Coffield nominates Bulldogs

I like it, the only issue being if Saints consider that fair. I think they should but who knows

True. But… Henry & 71 - for - Coffield (no games in 2 years) and 35.

SOS would be crazy to blow up getting Henry in considering Gresham & Shiel have both now blown up.

[hujsh]

Re: Nick Coffield nominates Bulldogs

True. But… Henry & 71 - for - Coffield (no games in 2 years) and 35.

SOS would be crazy to blow up getting Henry in considering Gresham & Shiel have both now blown up.

That's assuming you look at it as a whole. SOS might say 'nah you should pay up more for Coffield and we'll worry about Henry'

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Nick Coffield nominates Bulldogs

That's assuming you look at it as a whole. SOS might say 'nah you should pay up more for Coffield and we'll worry about Henry'

Then SOS can not have Henry and lose Coffield in the PSD. If we show Coffield good faith by including a second and two fourth rounders to get him we’ve done our part to get him to walk for free.

I don’t rate SOS, but surely he’s not that silly/stubborn?

[Axe Man]

Re: Nick Coffield nominates Bulldogs

True. But? Henry & 71 - for - Coffield (no games in 2 years) and 35.

SOS would be crazy to blow up getting Henry in considering Gresham & Shiel have both now blown up.

Why has Gresham blown up? If Saints get end of first round compo seems like they will take it (and it seems a reasonable chance based on the other compo so far):

ST KILDA would be comfortable matching Essendon's contract offer to Jade Gresham if it does not trigger end of first-round compensation for the restricted free agent.

The Bombers plan to lodge paperwork for Gresham in the next 24 hours and list manager Adrian Dodoro said the club had not yet been in talks with the Saints as they look to secure the 26-year-old without negotiating a trade.

St Kilda's acting football boss David Misson, however, said Gresham would only move as a free agent if the Bombers' offer triggered adequate compensation, with the club "hoping to get an end of first-round pick".

"The ball really is in Essendon's court there to lodge an offer for Jade. Once that's done, we need to decide if we're going to match that offer and potentially facilitate a trade," Misson told SEN on Wednesday.

"If the compensation we get offered isn't what we'd like, then we would decide whether we want to match it. Jade has a great relationship with Ross (Lyon), so if we have to we'd be very happy to keep Jade at St Kilda if that's the way it starts to look." ? Nathan Schmook

[hujsh]

Re: Nick Coffield nominates Bulldogs

Then SOS can not have Henry and lose Coffield in the PSD. If we show Coffield good faith by including a second and two fourth rounders to get him we’ve done our part to get him to walk for free.

I don’t rate SOS, but surely he’s not that silly/stubborn?

Yeah guess it depends on if they think there's a way to do it without us. I'm comforted by the presence of the PSD regardless

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Nick Coffield nominates Bulldogs

Why has Gresham blown up? If Saints get end of first round compo seems like they will take it (and it seems a reasonable chance based on the other compo so far):

I thought I read it didn’t get a first and Aints wanted to trade?

But that’s by the by for this.

[GVGjr]

Re: Nick Coffield nominates Bulldogs

Then SOS can not have Henry and lose Coffield in the PSD. If we show Coffield good faith by including a second and two fourth rounders to get him we’ve done our part to get him to walk for free.

I don’t rate SOS, but surely he’s not that silly/stubborn?

SOS is pragmatic and gets deals done. Not sure he has the stones to push Coffield into the PSD so a deal like you have proposed might appeal.