Tweet
Re: TRIBUNAL NEWS. Lake and Welsh get a week each
If i remember rightly Goodes did it far worse twice last year and didnt even get cited
If i remember rightly Goodes did it far worse twice last year and didnt even get cited
-
Bring back the biff -
Re: TRIBUNAL NEWS. Lake and Welsh get a week each
Richmond dont have that big destroying forward..but you would expect Simmonds to be up there at some stage...need Tommy back for sure.
No Welsh...Maybe Murph is ready to get back into it? If not please go with Okeefe..give the kid a chance!Comment
-
Re: TRIBUNAL NEWS. Lake and Welsh get a week each
Lake will play, he will get off that..was a bull$#$@ suspension!Comment
-
Re: TRIBUNAL NEWS. Lake and Welsh get a week each
Did any of the Sydney players get reported? The #30 (Roberts Hyphenated-Name) should have been reported for a fist to the face, and I'm pretty sure The Thug (aka Barry Hall) should have been reported as well...Comment
-
Re: TRIBUNAL NEWS. Lake and Welsh get a week each
Crap.... didn't see the Lake incident, but a week for tripping? God, put skirts on 'em all, call it netball and be done with it!
The Welsh bump I thought was a good one. But these days, hit a bloke within two feet of the head and they'll put you out...
Shit, this game now worries me!
EDIT - just saw the Lake "trip" - absolute rubbish...if the tribunal has ANY credibility, he'll get off. Pathetic.[B][COLOR="#0000CD"]Our club was born in blood and boots, not in AFL focus groups.[/COLOR][/B]Comment
-
Re: TRIBUNAL NEWS. Lake and Welsh get a week each
Can't believe Welsh got a week for that, has the bump gone?
Did Lake have carry over points?Comment
-
Re: TRIBUNAL NEWS. Lake and Welsh get a week each
Murphy is back this week - so no harm done there. Big loss Lake, but they don't have any powerful big forwards anyway - so good game to lose him (I hope)
Comment
-
Re: TRIBUNAL NEWS. Lake and Welsh get a week each
Another brain fade from Brian. Really stupid act and there is probably no point fighting it.
I have only seen the Welsh incident once so it's a bit hard to form an opinion from that, but I think that from what I have seen the bump was ok and it might be worth fighting it.
Opens up an opportunity for either one of our returning injured players or possibly another chance for one of our younger players.Comment
-
Re: TRIBUNAL NEWS. Lake and Welsh get a week each
I didn't see the incident, but 225 points means that I would probably err on the side of caution and not challenge it. We can afford to miss him for a week, but anymore than that and I wouldn't be so happy.
For interests sake, how many carry over points did Brian have?Have you heard Butters wants to come to the Dogs?Comment
-
Re: TRIBUNAL NEWS. Lake and Welsh get a week each
I can't believe Gardiners strike may only cost him one game. It was an intentional elbow to the head, behind play and the video evidence was so good you could even see him watching the player as he did it. If the player went down, made it look a bit worse (or got a bit of concussion) he would be looking at 5.
How many did Murphy get for that accidental front on one last year? Wasn't it two?
The system sucks.Comment
-
Re: TRIBUNAL NEWS. Lake and Welsh get a week each
What a rort! I cant believe the Lake decision.Comment
-
Re: TRIBUNAL NEWS. Lake and Welsh get a week each
Yes but, the force in which Gardiner used wasn't that great, was never going to knock him out, compare that to the Welsh incident, and he was running in, had the momentum up and went flush to the side of Crouches head with the shoulder, the elbow came out past his head which made it look like he may have missed, he sure didn't miss and crouch stayed hit!!!Comment
-
Re: TRIBUNAL NEWS. Lake and Welsh get a week each
I didn't see that one so I can't really comment, but it was a decent elbow from Gardiner and he certainly tried to hit him hard. The one I was referring to was the Murphy one from last year where he copped a few weeks for head high contact when he accidentally got the guy as he came in front on (had no time to pull up etc).Comment
-
Re: TRIBUNAL NEWS. Lake and Welsh get a week each
Welsh had his eyes on Crouch most of the way, he wanted to take him out!
With Murph's, he re-arranged Ellis's face somewhat, and you know how they go, the more damage caused, the bigger penalty, which is fair enough.Comment
-
Re: TRIBUNAL NEWS. Lake and Welsh get a week each
Has Welsh accepted the one match suspension? Is there any news on whether the club are going to challenge it? I think he'd get off. I don't see anything wrong with the bump. If both Lake and Welsh are out, I'd say bring Williams and Murphy in.Comment
Comment