If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
ADELAIDE midfielder Nathan van Berlo will captain the Crows next year after winning a player vote.
The Crows announced this morning coaches and the board had ratified a vote by the players to install the 24-year-old as the replacement for the retired Simon Goodwin.
[COLOR="Red"][B][U][COLOR="Blue"]85, 92, 97, 98, 08, 09, 10... Break the curse![/COLOR][/U][/B][/COLOR]
Boyd gets the pill and in heavy traffic and a fair bit of it. But his disposal and decision making can be suspect....in fact, sometimes terrible. I would have thought he should be concentrating on improving his game, as I think, that if we had an alternative with more elite skills, would he still get a game? With our recruiting we seem to be chasing leg speed, defensive pressure and in some instances, elite disposal. Since we have Cross, can we afford Boyd as well? Leave him out and we lose a ball gatherer, include him and we get a player whose disposal causes direct turnovers, something which we need to eliminate if we are to go the next level.
So we might get a captain who excels in all areas except where it counts most for us to improve. Is that a wise thing to do?
I'm far from convinced that Cooney would be a good selection for reasons I mentioned a few times. Morris isn't in the running but should be so it comes down to Boyd. Giansiracusa could do the job well but his form and longevity in the game won't work for him.
Cross could do the job as well but would be a short term prospect.
Originally posted by GVGjr
I know we will disagree on this but I can't have Cooney as a potential captain for next season. I have just witnessed some less than impressive performances at some functions to accept that the players could take him seriously as a leader.
Originally posted by Mantis
But they do.
Originally posted by Mantis
When was this may I ask?
The reason for asking was that as told to me if we were to change capatins this time last year Adam would have no chance, but through the 2010 seaosn he grew into his leadership role and the players responded to him... No doubt the issues you raised are valid, but perhaps next time you see him at a club function you might see someone worthy of representing our club as team capatain, or perhaps not.
Originally posted by DoggyStyle
Not that I want Gia as captain, but to suggest that the Club would not appoint him because of pressure from the fans is somewhat fanciful.
I'll concede it would be easy for the club to make a popular appointment with the fans, however the fans opinion is definitely last on a very long list (if at all) of criteria.
Sorry for multi-quoting so many but I want to comment on all ...
GVGjr, I have to disagree with you.
When the Bulldogs came over to Perth this year to play the Weasels, I had the opportunity to go into the inner sanctum and watch the boys prepare for the game. I watched the main players (Johnno, Cooney, Gia, Boyd, Cross, Huddo, Hall) very intently and was surprised with what I saw ...
Johnno was around to every player assuring them of their role and building confidence in their abilities at the same time. Every other player went about their business preparing for the game ... some walked around with iPods (Gia included) most making sure they got taped / massaged / hydrated etc. except for one.
Cooney was also round to every player, chatting with them about the game, their opponent, their role and like Johnno instilling confidence ... most importantly, the players were listening and reacting positively to him. This (and the training track and team meetings) is where it matters most, so from this it is very easy to see that the players definitely see him as a leader of this club.
I am pretty confident Doggy Style that the Bulldogs will make a choice that has fans approval. This obviously wont be the only criteria, but it will be a main one. If Gia is unpopular then he is definitely out of the running.
A changing of the guard is tempting after 3 prelims, going with one of the younger brigade,
as opposed to a continuation of sorts with the captain coming from the older (27 -30) more established group of leaders.
Cooney, Higgins, Ward, Griffin - Potentially very exciting , dynamic leadership group. All A graders. This would be a great core leadership group in a few years time. Just not sure they are all ready yet.
Comment