Ins and outs vs Sydney

[LostDoggy]

Who do you think should come in and out next weekend?

[Ghost Dog]

Re: Ins and outs vs Sydney

Wait and see what the injury list does I guess. I am unsure about Hill. I would rather a good hard tagger ( Liam Picken! an unsung hero and boy do we miss him ) or a hard nut like Moles.
The great lesson of last night is the ability of having flexibility in the team, guys that can play forward or back like Lake.

[G-Mo77]

Re: Ins and outs vs Sydney

Wait and see what the injury list does I guess.

This.

Apparently Hall's hammy was sore and I saw Gilbee grimacing and holding his hamstring late in the 4th.

Would Minson have came into the side last night had it had been dry? Did Hill do enough to keep his spot? Same goes with Stack? I'll wait a few more days before I give my In's and Out's.

[Rocco Jones]

Re: Ins and outs vs Sydney

I was pleased to see we tried to remedy our top heavy issues last night playing only one specialist ruckman. If we are going to bring back Will, I really hope it's at the expense of Williams.

[Go_Dogs]

Re: Ins and outs vs Sydney

I'd really like for us to stick with the same line up for this weeks game.

If someone goes out with an injury, perhaps a good opportunity to add Wood in for a taste.

Minson may come back into the selection frame, but I agree with RJ that hopefully it's not at the expense of another runner.

Sydney have historically been a heavy clearance/congestion style side, but I think they are playing a much more open style of footy this year, and as such, ensuring we have enough run will be important.

[Sedat]

Re: Ins and outs vs Sydney

I reckon Harbrow is in a spot of bother for his late hit on Bennell. At best he will get 90-odd points and a reprimand, but I wouldn't be the slightest bit surprised if he gets a week. That will bring Wood into calculations you'd imagine.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Ins and outs vs Sydney

I reckon Harbrow is in a spot of bother for his late hit on Bennell. At best he will get 90-odd points and a reprimand, but I wouldn't be the slightest bit surprised if he gets a week. That will bring Wood into calculations you'd imagine.

Nothing in it, If he gets done for that i will stop following the footy

[G-Mo77]

Re: Ins and outs vs Sydney

I reckon Harbrow is in a spot of bother for his late hit on Bennell. At best he will get 90-odd points and a reprimand, but I wouldn't be the slightest bit surprised if he gets a week. That will bring Wood into calculations you'd imagine.

He'd be very unlucky to even get a reprimand IMO.

[Ghost Dog]

Re: Ins and outs vs Sydney

It was pretty hard to see from the angle. Here's hoping he gets off lightly as he is the little giant of our team if you measured a player on pure hunger.

[Sedat]

Re: Ins and outs vs Sydney

Nothing in it, If he gets done for that i will stop following the footy

Bennell's post-match shiner must have happened on its own? Jarrod did get him late and high - there was no malice in it whatsoever but it is certain to get looked at, and it is on the cusp of suspension IMO.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Ins and outs vs Sydney

Bennell's post-match shiner must have happened on its own? Jarrod did get him late and high - there was no malice in it whatsoever but it is certain to get looked at, and it is on the cusp of suspension IMO.

I would say that at least 1 player every game gets a shiner and it does not mean that a suspension is in order. He went to block the ball and missed and got Bennells face, IMO nothing in it at all we will have to agree to disagree

[LostDoggy]

Re: Ins and outs vs Sydney

Hargrave and Hill out for mine. I think Hargrave has just about used up all his credits and its time for a spell at Willi, and Hill needs to drop back as well (especially coming up against Sydney), he is just not strong enough in the contest.

I think its time for Wood to come in, plus one of Roughy or Minnow. Give Johnno another week off.

[GVGjr]

Re: Ins and outs vs Sydney

Hargrave and Hill out for mine. I think Hargrave has just about used up all his credits and its time for a spell at Willi, and Hill needs to drop back as well (especially coming up against Sydney), he is just not strong enough in the contest.

I think its time for Wood to come in, plus one of Roughy or Minnow. Give Johnno another week off.

What do you think Wood is doing well enough to earn a promotion?

[LostDoggy]

Re: Ins and outs vs Sydney

Hargrave and Hill out for mine. I think Hargrave has just about used up all his credits and its time for a spell at Willi, and Hill needs to drop back as well (especially coming up against Sydney), he is just not strong enough in the contest.

I think its time for Wood to come in, plus one of Roughy or Minnow. Give Johnno another week off.

What has Wood done to displace Hargrave? Let Wood dominate at VFL level before you call for him to replace one of our most important players. Great teams have a core of backmen and IMO Hargrave, Lake and Morris are our core backmen

[LongWait]

Re: Ins and outs vs Sydney

What has Wood done to displace Hargrave? Let Wood dominate at VFL level before you call for him to replace one of our most important players. Great teams have a core of backmen and IMO Hargrave, Lake and Morris are our core backmen

Harbrow is easily our best backman on form this year. Shaggy easily our worst backman on form this year. Shaggy was just bloody awful last night.