Gia v/s Aker

[MrMahatma]

Re: Gia v/s Aker

Wow!

Who were we talking about again....?

[Bulldog4332]

Re: Gia v/s Aker

Wow!

Who were we talking about again....?

I officially request that this thread which I started be consigned to the dustbin.

[Bulldog4332]

Re: Gia v/s Aker

Bulldog 4332
Have a look at his disposal efficiency, it is poor. He often misses targets both by hand and foot. It works like this, Gia tries to spot up a leading target, misses and then slaps his thigh. It happens all the time.

Disposal efficency 2010:

Gia - 72.8% - 12th of all players

Aker - 66% - 27th of all players

I have asked for this thread to be closed but I cannot resist, so our leading small forward (or small goal making/creating forward) is not in the top 11 disposers of the pill. Take out Hudson and Minson so Gia is not in the top 13 players, gee that sort of makes my point I believe. He does not kick goals, he cannot hit targets so that leaves him with tackles and shepherds, I suppose you will pull out the 1% stats.

[Scorlibo]

Re: Gia v/s Aker

I have asked for this thread to be closed but I cannot resist, so our leading small forward (or small goal making/creating forward) is not in the top 11 disposers of the pill. Take out Hudson and Minson so Gia is not in the top 13 players, gee that sort of makes my point I believe. He does not kick goals, he cannot hit targets so that leaves him with tackles and shepherds, I suppose you will pull out the 1% stats.

For the position he plays, his efficiency is very good. More effective disposals than any other forward, and he's the guy bringing it inside fifty. Excellent effort on that basis.

[Scorlibo]

Re: Gia v/s Aker

Votes for Gia this season in the WOOF Player Awards: 11 (6th)

Supercoach score: 89.56 (7th)

On that note, I agree, close the thread.

[Topdog]

Re: Gia v/s Aker

I have asked for this thread to be closed but I cannot resist, so our leading small forward (or small goal making/creating forward) is not in the top 11 disposers of the pill. Take out Hudson and Minson so Gia is not in the top 13 players, gee that sort of makes my point I believe. He does not kick goals, he cannot hit targets so that leaves him with tackles and shepherds, I suppose you will pull out the 1% stats.

Wow now you are really taking your bias too far. Suggest you read the stats again and replace the word Gia with a player you like. You will be pleasantly surprised.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Gia v/s Aker

Gia is king of the orange people...

[boydogs]

Re: Gia v/s Aker

Votes for Gia this season in the WOOF Player Awards: 11 (6th)

Supercoach score: 89.56 (7th)

On that note, I agree, close the thread.

These numbers are hugely biased by Gia's midfield games. The numbers for Gia as a forward would be far less impressive.

By rating him on these measures, you are essentially pressing the case for Gia to be moved out of the forward line and into the midfield, which I agree with