Round 21 - WOOF Selection Table

[Before I Die]

Re: Round 21 - WOOF Selection Table

Rose may miss a few weeks due to rolling his ankle at training today in a bruising session [he looked in alot of pain], which also saw Gilbee, Moles & Jones needing treatment. [on the CH10 news].

That's very unfortunate. The pain may have been more than just physical if the whisper I mentioned earlier was correct. Hopefully there is no serious damage and any swelling subsides quickly.

[becmatty]

Re: Round 21 - WOOF Selection Table

Who cares about Hahn's record against the Bombers? We won't be playing against them in September, so why base his selection on it?

Hahn has lost what little mobility he had, and for those talking up his performance for Willy on the weekend - they were playing a team that would struggle to win in the EDFL. 2 goals and 20 odd possessions in a 12 goal rout means absolutely nothing.

If he is in our 22 come the first final, the likes of O'Brien, Shaw and Maxwell will be sleeping in the change rooms prior to the game in the hope they can get first crack at him.

Regardless of finalsm we need to win against the Bombers first in order to sew up a top four spot. So, Mitch's domination over the years against the Bombers will be a consideration with his selection in round 22.

I hope he gets a game.

[comrade]

Re: Round 21 - WOOF Selection Table

Regardless of finalsm we need to win against the Bombers first in order to sew up a top four spot. So, Mitch's domination over the years against the Bombers will be a consideration with his selection in round 22.

I hope he gets a game.

If we can't beat the Bombers without Mitch Hahn, we may as well not show up against Collingwood.

[becmatty]

Re: Round 21 - WOOF Selection Table

Every week you quote the coach.

At some stage you will have to accept that what he says to the media is in no way associated with his plans for the weekend.

Eade's comments to the media early in the week about team selection are very much in the 'rumor' category.

The coach is saying it, the papers are saying it, I am saying it: We have 4 stars ready to return, as well as Hahn pressing for selection. What part of 4-6 changes sounds like a rumour then??!

[GVGjr]

Re: Round 21 - WOOF Selection Table

The coach is saying it, the papers are saying it, I am saying it: We have 4 stars ready to return, as well as Hahn pressing for selection. What part of 4-6 changes sounds like a rumour then??!

I heard it on SEN as well saying that as many as 5 changes could happen.

[Mantis]

Re: Round 21 - WOOF Selection Table

The coach is saying it, the papers are saying it, I am saying it: We have 4 stars ready to return, as well as Hahn pressing for selection. What part of 4-6 changes sounds like a rumour then??!

I would hardly take it as fact you're saying it.

Your track record at picking the ins and outs is downright embarrassing.

[becmatty]

Re: Round 21 - WOOF Selection Table

I would hardly take it as fact you're saying it.

Your track record at picking the ins and outs is downright embarrassing.

Nor you Mantis. Thats why we are not on the MC, but having discussion as supporters on this forum.

[Desipura]

Re: Round 21 - WOOF Selection Table

Nor you Mantis. Thats why we are not on the MC, but having discussion as supporters on this forum.

I would hardly take it as fact you're saying it.

Your track record at picking the ins and outs is downright embarrassing.

No offence BecMatty. Mantis and I have had our fair share of run ins however I would back Mantis's information over yours any day of the week!
If Mantis's information is not 100%, it is not that far off the mark. As opposed to your information which is at the other end of the scale.
Mantis does not need me to back him up, just thought I would make this point.

[becmatty]

Re: Round 21 - WOOF Selection Table

No offence BecMatty. Mantis and I have had our fair share of run ins however I would back Mantis's information over yours any day of the week!
If Mantis's information is not 100%, it is not that far off the mark. As opposed to your information which is at the other end of the scale.
Mantis does not need me to back him up, just thought I would make this point.

This forum is for providing your own opinions. If my selections differ from yours or the MC, whoopee do.

I think its time you both to go back to Williamstown to regain some form.

[Mofra]

Re: Round 21 - WOOF Selection Table

I think its time you both to go back to Williamstown to regain some form.

Lets be honest here, even Travis Cloke has you covered for conversion rate

[Desipura]

Re: Round 21 - WOOF Selection Table

This forum is for providing your own opinions. If my selections differ from yours or the MC, whoopee do.

I think its time you both to go back to Williamstown to regain some form.

Every day you give a different opinion on team selections. Im sure you read the paper each day and see what someone writes then change your opinion accordingly.
Sometimes less information is better.
I think you need to go to Williamstown as you are yet to hit a target.

[Bornadog]

Re: Round 21 - WOOF Selection Table

This forum is for providing your own opinions. If my selections differ from yours or the MC, whoopee do.

I think its time you both to go back to Williamstown to regain some form.

Keep your opinions coming Becmatty, thats what the forum is all about.

We all have our opinions and information passed on from various friends relatives and even inside the club itself. However, we all must realize the MC and the coaches can change their mind anytime depending on the fitness and player circumstances or even who the opposition is selecting.

[mjp]

Re: Round 21 - WOOF Selection Table

The coach is saying it, the papers are saying it, I am saying it: We have 4 stars ready to return, as well as Hahn pressing for selection. What part of 4-6 changes sounds like a rumour then??!

Hmmm. Yet last week you told us Harbrow would play because Eade said so. Would you call that a fact or a rumor?

Everything Eade says about selection can be put in the 'rumors' category. Every week.

I would actually prefer to just hear about what you think will happen and why rather than have you quote the coach because he blatantly tells mistruths to the press.

[EasternWest]

Re: Round 21 - WOOF Selection Table

I would hardly take it as fact you're saying it.

Your track record at picking the ins and outs is downright embarrassing.

Bit harsh Mantis.

I poke a bit of fun at becmatty too, but I like that he's willing to put it out there. At least, I always read his threads. It's true they're not always correct, but I'd rather he'd put them out there than be henpecked into silence for being bold.

[GVGjr]

Re: Round 21 - WOOF Selection Table

I poke a bit of fun at becmatty too, but I like that he's willing to put it out there.

I don't mind the way he challenges the status quo either but the weekly selections need to be a bit closer to the mark.