Round #2 Match Committee

[GVGjr]

OK, who are the likely ins and outs for the game against the Lions?

[SlimPickens]

Re: Round #2 Match Committee

Ins: DFA and minson
Outs: jones and stack


I would really like to see the match committee make an example of some senior players much like st Kilda did a few years ago. Unfortunately I don't see us dropping the skipper.

[Ozza]

Re: Round #2 Match Committee

Out: Markovic, Djerrkerra; Jones

In: Lake, Wallis; Minson

[DOG GOD]

Re: Round #2 Match Committee

With JBrown out, i wouldnt be surprised to not risk Lake if he's not 100% so...

Out: Djerrkerra (inj) Wood (inj)
In: Minson Addison

[Hotdog60]

Re: Round #2 Match Committee

Ins: DFA and minson
Outs: jones and stack


I would really like to see the match committee make an example of some senior players much like st Kilda did a few years ago. Unfortunately I don't see us dropping the skipper.

I like DFA as in, Wood maybe an out through injury.

Lake will come back as Brown will be out and give Lake half a game.

Ins DFA, Lake(Sub).

Out Stack, Wood (inj) or Jones if Wood is ok

[Dazza]

Re: Round #2 Match Committee

Out : Markovic, Wood

In: Lake, Addison

** I think Jones needs time in the team. Made position well but couldn't stick his marks. Used the ball well when he had the chance.
*** Dropping cross was tempting. With players like Moles and Wallis waiting in the wings he'd want to perform much better than he did today.
**** Would get Roughead in if he is right to go.

[jazzadogs]

Re: Round #2 Match Committee

With JBrown out, i wouldnt be surprised to not risk Lake if he's not 100% so...

Out: Djerrkerra (inj) Wood (inj)
In: Minson Addison

Didn't know Djerkurra had been injured...any word on this?

Wood's injury is a huge setback.

In: Addison, Lake (assuming he's ready), Minson
Out: Wood (inj), Jones, Markovic


I'm sure this will be discussed on almost every thread, but I don't see how we can afford to use Williams as our second ruck. Hudson is an underrated player, but that doesn't mean we can expect him and our CHB to dominate the ruck for an entire match.

Even expecting Williams to ruck, then go back and cover the resting ruckman. It's a lot easier for Minson/Roughy to ruck then go forward, because when you go forward you are, to a degree, controlling how much you have to run and can actually have a rest. The one ruckman strategy may work against some teams, but there are better options than Williams ie Barlow, Skinner.

EDIT: should also say that Jones is being dropped for balance, because with Minson in we may be too top-heavy, not because Jones had a necessarily bad game.

[SquirrelGrip]

Re: Round #2 Match Committee

Out: Djerkerra, Wood (both inj), Jones, Boyd, Giansiracusa
In: Wallis, Addison, Minson, Skinner, Veszpremi

Where was our Captain today?

[Max469]

Re: Round #2 Match Committee

Where was our Captain today?

MISSING IN ACTION

[DOG GOD]

Re: Round #2 Match Committee

Didn't know Djerkurra had been injured...any word on this?

He was subbed off for Sherman and was sitting on the bench with an ice pack under his leg, so maybe a hamstring?

[EasternWest]

Re: Round #2 Match Committee

Heard someone mentionin the radio that Picken has broken jaw. Is this true? That would make him a forced out too I guess?

[Bulldog Joe]

Re: Round #2 Match Committee

IN
A second ruckman or we can out the entire match committee.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round #2 Match Committee

Without definitely knowing the injuries I would say...

Out stack, jones
In Addison, minson or roughy as sub

[Happy Days]

Re: Round #2 Match Committee

In: Minson, Lake, Wallis

Out: Jones, Stack, Wood

Don't think we should waste Sherman as the sub again; unique idea to use it in conjunction with a burst player, but realistically its made for a second ruck.

[Scorlibo]

Re: Round #2 Match Committee

What happened to Wood and DJ?