Fantasia on SEN 12.25pm today (13/10/11)

[Maddog37]

Re: Fantasia on SEN 12.25pm today (13/10/11)

Of all the second hand players chatted about the only ones I would be interested in are the Collingwood boys. Setanta has a crack, Bate has played some good games and Bower is not totally horrible but looks like a rabbit in the headlights at times.

On a side note, Denham on SEN seems totally bored with trade week and is becoming more arrogant by the day. Really dislike him.

[Bornadog]

Re: Fantasia on SEN 12.25pm today (13/10/11)

We've been interested for months so I'm expecting him to be a Bulldog next year.
I basically see him as a Hahn type; perhaps slightly quicker and slightly taller but less bullocking.

Hahn was drafted at pick 37 - trying to take away any Bulldogs bias, that would be a starting point, discounted for the fact that he couldn't establish himself as a regular in the Melbourne side unlike Hahn as a Bulldog at a similar age so a later pick would be fairer value.

I'm expecting whatever pick we gain for Josh Hill to end up at Melbourne.

Bates Manager has confirmed he wants to be a Bulldog, lets see what happens.

[Mofra]

Re: Fantasia on SEN 12.25pm today (13/10/11)

Bates Manager has confirmed he wants to be a Bulldog, lets see what happens.

If Melbourne want to play hard-ball on a player that clearly doesn't want to be there good luck to them. I'm not sure what sort of return they expect, especially when he is out of contract in 12 months time.

[Topdog]

Re: Fantasia on SEN 12.25pm today (13/10/11)

Seriously Bate?? Im almost ready to give up on the year already.

Also LongWait the criticism of Fantasia has been happening long before Eades departure and if you want reasons for it look no further than last years trades and signings. We are stuck with Hooper and DJ on the main list for another 2 years.

[Mofra]

Re: Fantasia on SEN 12.25pm today (13/10/11)

Also LongWait the criticism of Fantasia has been happening long before Eades departure and if you want reasons for it look no further than last years trades and signings. We are stuck with Hooper and DJ on the main list for another 2 years.

Hooper has only 12 months left?
We also have Mulligan for another 12 months.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Fantasia on SEN 12.25pm today (13/10/11)

Bates Manager has confirmed he wants to be a Bulldog, lets see what happens.

Providing we can get him at the right price, I would be happoy with Bate.

I like left foot swoopers and he would provide something different to our forward line.

[Ghost Dog]

Re: Fantasia on SEN 12.25pm today (13/10/11)

Wait a sec, wait a sec.

I can't believe I'm about to white knight Setanta (who I don't mind, but don't particularly want) but what the footage doesn't show was Cloke punching O'Hailpin in the face when he wasn't looking.

Setanta, being the Irish lunatic he is was happy to settle it man to man but Cloke ran away. Pretty much the camera rolled on them when O'Hailpin caught up to him, and what we all saw was the end result.

It was ugly to watch, but hardly all Setanta's fault.

I was just kidding around. He wouldn't be so bad as a player but Carlton fans seem too happy to get rid of him for my liking.

The jab in cloke's butt with the boot made me LOL at the time. Always happy to see disarray in the Blues camp.

[Sedat]

Re: Fantasia on SEN 12.25pm today (13/10/11)

I was just kidding around. He wouldn't be so bad as a player but Carlton fans seem too happy to get rid of him for my liking.

Only because they have Warnock in the ruck, Kreuzer and Hampson ready to play 2nd ruck/forward next season (both were injured late this season, which is why Setanta played finals).

Setanta would give us cover in an area that we desperately need it, and he won't cost much to do so. He certainly didn;t disgrace himself in ther finals this season playing that ruck relief/forward role.

[Topdog]

Re: Fantasia on SEN 12.25pm today (13/10/11)

Hooper has only 12 months left?
We also have Mulligan for another 12 months.

Yep sorry, 1 more year of Hooper who didn't need to be promoted at all. A year to go for Mulligan too. Just madness

[Ghost Dog]

Re: Fantasia on SEN 12.25pm today (13/10/11)

Yep sorry, 1 more year of Hooper who didn't need to be promoted at all. A year to go for Mulligan too. Just madness

Every club makes clangers I guess.

[Ghost Dog]

Re: Fantasia on SEN 12.25pm today (13/10/11)

Only because they have Warnock in the ruck, Kreuzer and Hampson ready to play 2nd ruck/forward next season (both were injured late this season, which is why Setanta played finals).

Setanta would give us cover in an area that we desperately need it, and he won't cost much to do so. He certainly didn;t disgrace himself in ther finals this season playing that ruck relief/forward role.

The other thing is, we lose a bit of fear factor with Barry gone. I do admit, it would make us more entertaining...

[Mantis]

Re: Fantasia on SEN 12.25pm today (13/10/11)

Every club makes clangers I guess.

That's no excuse.

We strive to be better than everyone else and these types of blunders don't help.. especially when we are up against it to start with.

[Topdog]

Re: Fantasia on SEN 12.25pm today (13/10/11)

Every club makes clangers I guess.

And every person who makes multiple blunders need to be held accountable.

[Bulldog Revolution]

Re: Fantasia on SEN 12.25pm today (13/10/11)

A year to go for Mulligan too.

Is this is accurate. I thought Mulligan was out of contract.

[Mantis]

Re: Fantasia on SEN 12.25pm today (13/10/11)

Is this is accurate. I thought Mulligan was out of contract.

Yep, he is out of contract at the end of 2012.