Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

[Sedat]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

We have absolutely no idea whether Libba is being rested; is playing at Willi as part of a pre-determined player rotation policy; or if there are some issues about team rules.

He has been omitted according to selection. If he plays for Willy tomorrow that will be set in stone. If that's what actually transpires, I happen to disgaree vehemently with the decision for the reasons I have alluded to earlier. It is your prerogative to be happy to see Libba in the twos.

[F'scary]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

Wow. I thought I'd taken the loss hard.

sorry, maybe I got carried away just a bit. On the Sunday morning, I wasn't too bad. But then as the day went on, it just got worse and worse and I kept logging back in to express myself and it showed.

Anyway, maybe macca read my post because there has been a bit of movement in the selections.

[jeemak]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

He may well be not 100% fit and thus he was dropped because last year in his debut season he was very good. How do you think Sherman will go as he hasn't had the best pre-season.

I haven't managed to see him first hand this year, though I know he offers us pace and goal kicking ability based on past performance. His form at Willy seems to be trending positively so it's the right time to include him IMO.

I get frustrated with some of his decision making like most others however, he's a player with deficiencies like the majority of players in the league. The fact he carries on like a boofhead from time to time opens him up to a lot of negativity.

[Eastdog]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

I haven't managed to see him first hand this year, though I know he offers us pace and goal kicking ability based on past performance. His form at Willy seems to be trending positively so it's the right time to include him IMO.

I get frustrated with some of his decision making like most others however, he's a player with deficiencies like the majority of players in the league. The fact he carries on like a boofhead from time to time opens him up to a lot of negativity.

To me Sherman is the kind of player that can really be good but can also be really poor.

[1eyedog]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

I agree with most of your post and like DJ to get a fulll game and Wallis to get more game time then Smith this year.

But seriously Addison??? He has been the only consistant defender we have and not only does he try all day long, he has not been beaten yet and efficiency is 1 of the highest in the team. I think he has 100% efficiency against Adelaide and wouldnt be suprised if he had similar numbers against the saints. He was even presenting when Wood got caught by hayes in the backline but Wood decided to take Hayes on. Think Addison has earned his spot and should stay based on his current form.

I would have to retract my statement here and agree with you on this post and I just wanted to follow it up because I was wrong and probably judged Addision on his history rather than his current output.

I thought he was fantastic on Sunday and deserves his spot in the team. I hope his form continues.