Do we need more star players?

[Twodogs]

Re: Do we need more star players?

There are probably players like Rioli and Ah Chee that have that really classy quality about them that could slip to our picks. Great players to have but would we take them at the expense of players that fit a few other of our needs?

We are going to need a lightning pace/smart ball user just as much as a key defender to be a really complete team. So an Ah Chee or Rioli is picking to need. A bit earlier than we have to I suppose but we will need that type of player eventually. I'd love a Rioli in the team.

Is a defence of Roberts, Hamling and Cordy 'big' enough?

Re: OP - you can never have enough star players.

Probably not. We will need a bigger type but he will play a different role. Zaine will be competing with Roberts and Hamling for the third tall role and I reckon he's a better prospect than both of them.

Do you think that Ayce's general failure / spudness might have pushed down the 'price' for Zaine?

Maybe. It's an interesting question. Maybe the recruiters didn't pay Zaine enough regard after seeing Ayce at senior level.

[The Bulldogs Bite]

Re: Do we need more star players?

I think the star quality is not so obvious in this draft. There's certainly some gems near the top of the pecking order but I wouldn't be surprised if in a few years time we are shaking our heads in disbelief that a star player selected with a low pick could have been so overlooked.

I have no doubt that a clever recruiter or two will pull a surprise with one of their selections that will send the internet draft junkies into a state of hysteria and outrage (one of my enjoyments on draft day!).

Nothing more is guaranteed.

FWIW I think the star factor v needs has to be played on merits. If the quality KPD's we rated are simply not there come our first two picks, then I'd rather us draft the likes of Ah Chee/Rioli/Fiorini etc. and take Adams/Skinner with our third. It'd be unfortunate if it panned out that way (eg. McKay gone) but you make the most of the situation and add two (hopeful) stars.

[GVGjr]

Re: Do we need more star players?

Not being too familiar with draftees but do you mean a player such as a Wingard or a Betts type? Players who can dazzle rather than players who meet our specific needs.

It is hard to say. For our first two I would go best player available and from then on probably specific needs such as a key backman. It depends on what is available.

It certainly doesn't hurt to have a couple of star players who can make an impact in their first couple of seasons. Provides us with depth and cover.

No, it's specific to this year and probably Ah Chee and Rioli. Both players are potential sliders but I think we have more pressing needs, I'm asking if people think we should overlook them despite their potential star quality because we have other needs?