Your Rolling Top 5 - AFL National Draft 2018

[ledge]

Re: Your Rolling Top 5 - AFL National Draft 2018

I am a centrals supporter so I’ve been keeping an eye on Hately, he has been extremely good at senior level, would love to get him, but I get the feeling he will be gone by our pick. Especially if the SA clubs are after home grown.

[SlimPickens]

Re: Your Rolling Top 5 - AFL National Draft 2018

I am a centrals supporter so I’ve been keeping an eye on Hately, he has been extremely good at senior level, would love to get him, but I get the feeling he will be gone by our pick. Especially if the SA clubs are after home grown.

Agree reminds me of Ollie Wines. Big, powerful mid made for afl. I would take him over the others mentioned at our pick.

[bulldogsthru&thru]

Re: Your Rolling Top 5 - AFL National Draft 2018

https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-trade-news-melbournes-jesse-hogan-to-be-traded-to-fremantle-for-two-first-round-picks-per-report/news-story/e92c18b5e65ed195ac784af724b532e6

This deal could help us land Bailey Smith at pick 7

[GVGjr]

Re: Your Rolling Top 5 - AFL National Draft 2018

https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl...784af724b532e6

This deal could help us land Bailey Smith at pick 7

I wonder who Port would be targeting in that scenario? Maybe Rankine and if so, does that mean they might be more open to trading Wingard?

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Your Rolling Top 5 - AFL National Draft 2018

I wonder who Port would be targeting in that scenario? Maybe Rankine and if so, does that mean they might be more open to trading Wingard?

Assuming pick 6 is on the table for Wingard as per Sam McClure say so. They maybe grab Rankine & Rozee/Hately in the top 10, if all that eventuated That's got to make them pretty happy in replacing Wingard & Polec in the medium to long term.

[bulldogsthru&thru]

Re: Your Rolling Top 5 - AFL National Draft 2018

I wonder who Port would be targeting in that scenario? Maybe Rankine and if so, does that mean they might be more open to trading Wingard?

I’m thinking Rankine

[Go_Dogs]

Re: Your Rolling Top 5 - AFL National Draft 2018

Did I miss something with this proposed three team trade? How do Port get pick 9 AND 10?

Could we potentially look at a deal that saw us trade our pick for 2 picks in that 10-15 range? Maybe one of those picks can then be used in a Wingard deal (with something else from next year) and we can still get a first round player and West.

Shaping up to be the most intruiging drafts/trade periods with teams moving up and down in the order, and potentially having multiple picks. It makes it very hard to get a grasp on what players may be available.

[bulldogsthru&thru]

Re: Your Rolling Top 5 - AFL National Draft 2018

Did I miss something with this proposed three team trade? How do Port get pick 9 AND 10?

Could we potentially look at a deal that saw us trade our pick for 2 picks in that 10-15 range? Maybe one of those picks can then be used in a Wingard deal (with something else from next year) and we can still get a first round player and West.

Shaping up to be the most intruiging drafts/trade periods with teams moving up and down in the order, and potentially having multiple picks. It makes it very hard to get a grasp on what players may be available.

Pick 10 would be for Polec

[wimberga]

Re: Your Rolling Top 5 - AFL National Draft 2018

Did I miss something with this proposed three team trade? How do Port get pick 9 AND 10?

Could we potentially look at a deal that saw us trade our pick for 2 picks in that 10-15 range? Maybe one of those picks can then be used in a Wingard deal (with something else from next year) and we can still get a first round player and West.

Shaping up to be the most intruiging drafts/trade periods with teams moving up and down in the order, and potentially having multiple picks. It makes it very hard to get a grasp on what players may be available.

Port currently have pick 9 and are expected to receive 10 from North for Polec.

Agree that this could be a really intriguing trade period. I like 6 for Wingard or for another player like Jack Martin given we have West coming through as the age profile of our list is going to be seriously out of kilter next year. Given how young we are already and the players we have leaving, I would prefer to facilitate a trade for mature talent with our first pick. If we do go to the draft however, we are likely to end up with a player.

However, I would probably be against trading pick 6 for say, pick 15 and 20, as from all accounts the top 7-8 players in this draft are well ahead of the rest.

[GVGjr]

Re: Your Rolling Top 5 - AFL National Draft 2018

Did I miss something with this proposed three team trade? How do Port get pick 9 AND 10?

Could we potentially look at a deal that saw us trade our pick for 2 picks in that 10-15 range? Maybe one of those picks can then be used in a Wingard deal (with something else from next year) and we can still get a first round player and West.

Shaping up to be the most intruiging drafts/trade periods with teams moving up and down in the order, and potentially having multiple picks. It makes it very hard to get a grasp on what players may be available.

This is how I'm reading it

Port have picks 9 and 10 due to having their own pick and Norths pick for Polec
Neale to Brisbane for pick 4
Pick 4 to Port for picks 9 and 10
Picks 9 and 10 to Melbourne for Hogan

In summary:
Brisbane gain Neale and lose pick 4
Fremantle gain Hogan and lose pick 4 and Neale.
Port gain pick 4 and lose picks 9 and 10.
Melbourne gain picks 9 and 10 and lose Hogan

There is bound to be a bit more to this in terms of later pick swaps

[wimberga]

Re: Your Rolling Top 5 - AFL National Draft 2018

This is how I'm reading it

Port have picks 9 and 10 due to having their own pick and Norths pick for Polec
Neale to Brisbane for pick 4
Pick 4 to Port for picks 9 and 10
Picks 9 and 10 to Melbourne for Hogan

In summary:
Brisbane gain Neale and lose pick 4
Fremantle gain Hogan and lose pick 4 and Neale.
Port gain pick 4 and lose picks 9 and 10.
Melbourne gain picks 9 and 10 and lose Hogan

There is bound to be a bit more to this in terms of later pick swaps

That appears to be right given how I am reading it to GVG - however if that is all the trade ends up being, Brisbane and Port appear to have gotten relatively fair deals while Melbourne are winners and Freo lose out.

[GVGjr]

Re: Your Rolling Top 5 - AFL National Draft 2018

That appears to be right given how I am reading it to GVG - however if that is all the trade ends up being, Brisbane and Port appear to have gotten relatively fair deals while Melbourne are winners and Freo lose out.

I'm not so sure, Port will get something back because they gave up 2,850 draft points for 2,000 points. Melbourne might have to throw in something to go to Port

There will be swaps of other picks to even things out

[DOG GOD]

Re: Your Rolling Top 5 - AFL National Draft 2018

This is how I'm reading it

Port have picks 9 and 10 due to having their own pick and Norths pick for Polec
Neale to Brisbane for pick 4
Pick 4 to Port for picks 9 and 10
Picks 9 and 10 to Melbourne for Hogan

In summary:
Brisbane gain Neale and lose pick 4
Fremantle gain Hogan and lose pick 4 and Neale.
Port gain pick 4 and lose picks 9 and 10.
Melbourne gain picks 9 and 10 and lose Hogan

There is bound to be a bit more to this in terms of later pick swaps

Yep, that’s how I can see it panning out, and if we gave pick 6 for wingard, then that gives port picks 4 and 6 in a SA talented draft, with crows getting pick 8

[divvydan]

Re: Your Rolling Top 5 - AFL National Draft 2018

Freo gain Hogan and lose Neale. They don't lose Neale and pick 4. Would be a huge win for them imo, so they might have to give something else up. Not sure what as they only have one decent pick in the draft (5) and their next best pick is in the 70's. Maybe a 2nd rounder from next year back to Port, or something like that.

[GVGjr]

Re: Your Rolling Top 5 - AFL National Draft 2018

Freo gain Hogan and lose Neale. They don't lose Neale and pick 4. Would be a huge win for them imo, so they might have to give something else up. Not sure what as they only have one decent pick in the draft (5) and their next best pick is in the 70's. Maybe a 2nd rounder from next year back to Port, or something like that.

Fair point, they will need to add something to the mix I suspect, They have pick 5 so it will be folded into the deals