2013 Phantom Draft

[LostDoggy]

Re: 2013 Phantom Draft

Thanks for the effort MRM.

What are your thoughts on Freeman? A lot of people are really starting to rate his ability to burst through packs and play with that real explosiveness that few players bar dangerfield, cooney & judd have/had?

He didn't catch my eye Wim. That's nothing against him, that's more a blight on me as i've overlooked him.

[Axe Man]

Re: 2013 Phantom Draft

Callum Twomey on the AFL website has put out a list of his top 20 players at this early stage.

Phantom form guide

Dom Sheed at 17 seems a bit low given the wraps on him?

[bulldogtragic]

Re: 2013 Phantom Draft

Callum Twomey on the AFL website has put out a list of his top 20 players at this early stage.

Phantom form guide

Dom Sheed at 17 seems a bit low given the wraps on him?

I've only seen a little of Sheed, but he would be a crazy good get at pick 17. I'd be happy to trade up to get him ala Lake last year.

No Garlett either.... He must not be reformed according to Twomey because his stats this year are rediculously great....

[SlimPickens]

Re: 2013 Phantom Draft

I've only seen a little of Sheed, but he would be a crazy good get at pick 17. I'd be happy to trade up to get him ala Lake last year.

No Garlett either.... He must not be reformed according to Twomey because his stats this year are rediculously great....

I'd say he was only looking at the field post championships, so Garlett didn't factor.

[LostDoggy]

Re: 2013 Phantom Draft

Great effort MRM disagree on a couple of spots but think you're pretty much on the money.

Whick ones SP ?

[Remi Moses]

Re: 2013 Phantom Draft

Very good effort MRM.
Be happy with those two selections

[Bornadog]

Re: 2013 Phantom Draft

Very good effort MRM.
Be happy with those two selections

take the twin brother as well

[boydogs]

Re: 2013 Phantom Draft

(mods, feel free to fix up the attachment so it shows if you can, cheers)

This is the list as a spreadsheet in case anyone wants to pick it up and edit it

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AhHFZM7tUyeYdF9oRXZ3ejN5amlJckl5elBYOEFad2c&usp=sharing

[mjp]

Re: 2013 Phantom Draft

Great effort. Some thoughts from me:

1. I like Kelly a lot-but think Aish and Scharenberg are clearly better.
2. Sheed at 3 is really, really high. It only takes one team I know, but he will be on the 2nd rung of mids with Crouch, Freeman and Dunstan...Taylor, Kelly and Aish will go first I think.
3. Billings is interesting...more forward than mid and small and slow...but very clever. Where he goes will be interesting. Very hyped though.
4. Lennon could go early as that HHF type is in high demand and he is the best of that sort.
5. Seems very early for Harvey and incredibly early for Steffe.
6. Hartung is unique and I think will go earlier...think Jetta (Sydney version) as a comparison.
7. KK will go quite a bit higher...versatile, aggressive and left footer.
8. I would be stunned if Gardiner lasted 10 picks. Gilles must come into it as a key tall.
9. Some say Salem is/was Metro's best player...seems low for me.
10. Way too high for Barass...Acres will fall due to injury...Fantasia is small, Honeychurch is smaller...can't see them as 1st rounders.

That'll do.

[mjp]

Re: 2013 Phantom Draft

take the twin brother as well

JK is a good player and might be a bargain in the 3rd round...then again, Tassie lost to Nsw and more importantly only kicked 4 goals for the day...so maybe everyone's thoughts about Templeton, KK, Nankervis etc are overblown.

[Remi Moses]

Re: 2013 Phantom Draft

JK is a good player and might be a bargain in the 3rd round...then again, Tassie lost to Nsw and more importantly only kicked 4 goals for the day...so maybe everyone's thoughts about Templeton, KK, Nankervis etc are overblown.

Thanks for your input .
Just your thoughts on McCarthy ?

[mjp]

Re: 2013 Phantom Draft

Thanks for your input .
Just your thoughts on McCarthy ?

Going to be a good player.

[wimberga]

Re: 2013 Phantom Draft

MJP - I'd be interested in your thoughts on what we should do with our first selection in 2013 (likely to be pick 3-5).

Do u think we package it up with something/someone to try and obtain Boyd (or someone else?)

If not, who do you think the dogs would like most? one of Aish, Scharenberg, and Kelly are likely to be available at our pick, who do u think would be best for us and if they are somehow gone, who else should we look to in your opinion?

[FrediKanoute]

Re: 2013 Phantom Draft

My feeling is that if no deal for Boyd is done and he doesn't fall to 3 in the draft, then we should take Scharenburg. Seems a good all round player and fits the 190+ forward/back/mid the game is moving to.

[Bornadog]

Re: 2013 Phantom Draft

My feeling is that if no deal for Boyd is done and he doesn't fall to 3 in the draft, then we should take Scharenburg. Seems a good all round player and fits the 190+ forward/back/mid the game is moving to.

We will finish 17th and we will get Boyd after GWS take Scharenburg