List Management 2015

[bulldogtragic]

Re: List Management 2015

Kelly BT?

That'd be him

You can see the obvious impact he's had on my memory of him

[LostDoggy]

Re: List Management 2015

Outs:

ML: Grant (wing), Cordy (project ruck), Fuller (injured), Darley (HBF), Talia (CHB)
RL: Goodes (HBF and experience), Pearce (HBF), Other dude (CHB)

Ins:

ML: Suckling (wing), Dunkley (big mid), Collins (full back), Adams (CHB), Williams (HBF)
RL: Goetz (project ruck), Lynch (HBF), Adcock (HBF and experience)

Player for Player:

Suckling for Grant
Collins for Talia
Williams for Fuller
Adams for Cordy (project ruck on rookie list though - where they should be)
Dunkley for Darley


Goetz for Other dude (extra defender on main list)
Adcock for Goodes
Lynch for Pearce


Got to say I think we are ahead on every single list decision. Not often you can say that. Big, big, big tick for me.

You must have a seriously strong opinion of Suckling BT

[bulldogtragic]

Re: List Management 2015

You must have a seriously strong opinion of Suckling BT

I'm in a transition phase weening off Jarrad. It's clear the club didn't rate him and Bevo is expecting Suckling to make an impact for us next year. On that basis, that puts us ahead on the basis the delisting and free agency pursuit were both voluntary by the club. My guess is he will be a bit more up the ground than he was at Hawthorn.

[LostDoggy]

Re: List Management 2015

I'm in a transition phase weening off Jarrad. It's clear the club didn't rate him and Bevo is expecting Suckling to make an impact for us next year. On that basis, that puts us ahead on the basis the delisting and free agency pursuit were both voluntary by the club. My guess is he will be a bit more up the ground than he was at Hawthorn.

One day at a time, you'll get there.

I'm curious to see how Suckling goes, to me his best value is when he can find time and space behind the ball, but Bevo does have a way of redefining what a bloke can offer.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: List Management 2015

One day at a time, you'll get there.

I'm curious to see how Suckling goes, to me his best value is when he can find time and space behind the ball, but Bevo does have a way of redefining what a bloke can offer.

Thanks PP. Grief is a process.

[LostDoggy]

Re: List Management 2015

Thanks PP. Grief is a process.

The first step is acknowledging your loss. You'll be ok, there are plenty of Jarrad's in the ocean.

[comrade]

Re: List Management 2015

The first step is acknowledging your loss. You'll be ok, there are plenty of Jarrad's in the ocean.

Scott Clayton will pass them as he swims to Williamstown.

[The Underdog]

Re: List Management 2015

The list certainly feels like it has a better balance to it. There's still plenty of inexperience in the key positions, although with plenty of potential. It's still a bit concerning how much still hinges on the development of T. Boyd and the ability of Minson / Campbell to stay fit and have an impact in the ruck. We're still not overly quick but if we move the ball the way we did through much of 2015 that doesn't seem to be an issue, at least until we get onto a bigger ground.
Considering the bizarre work of the match committee in 2015, the list management decisions seem to have been incredibly straight forward and sensible.
Now we just need a full season of Koby

[Bulldog4life]

Re: List Management 2015

The list certainly feels like it has a better balance to it. There's still plenty of inexperience in the key positions, although with plenty of potential. It's still a bit concerning how much still hinges on the development of T. Boyd and the ability of Minson / Campbell to stay fit and have an impact in the ruck. We're still not overly quick but if we move the ball the way we did through much of 2015 that doesn't seem to be an issue, at least until we get onto a bigger ground.
Considering the bizarre work of the match committee in 2015, the list management decisions seem to have been incredibly straight forward and sensible.

Now we just need a full season of Koby

As I said in another thread, on Wed. night Bevo said that Roughy will be training to play in the ruck and forward next season. That could change of course.

[The Underdog]

Re: List Management 2015

As I said in another thread, on Wed. night Bevo said that Roughy will be training to play in the ruck and forward next season. That could change of course.

Forgot about Roughy although health isn't a skill he's mastered yet. Could end up first choice though.

[Twodogs]

Re: List Management 2015

It depends on what sort of position the ruck evolves into next season. It keeps changing.

[Ghost Dog]

Re: List Management 2015

The list certainly feels like it has a better balance to it. There's still plenty of inexperience in the key positions, although with plenty of potential. It's still a bit concerning how much still hinges on the development of T. Boyd and the ability of Minson / Campbell to stay fit and have an impact in the ruck. We're still not overly quick but if we move the ball the way we did through much of 2015 that doesn't seem to be an issue, at least until we get onto a bigger ground.
Considering the bizarre work of the match committee in 2015, the list management decisions seem to have been incredibly straight forward and sensible.
Now we just need a full season of Koby

I'm curious as to why you think so. We have Redpath, Collins who could easily play forward, and Stringer. If we didn't have Tom Boyd presently I would still fell confident in our list. He is not going to be the superman who saves us. He's only there to play one role, an important one but not irreplaceable.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: List Management 2015

As I said in another thread, on Wed. night Bevo said that Roughy will be training to play in the ruck and forward next season. That could change of course.

He also kept bringing up Kobys name. I feel he's a coaches favourite or that was my take listening to Bevo,

[The Underdog]

Re: List Management 2015

I'm curious as to why you think so. We have Redpath, Collins who could easily play forward, and Stringer. If we didn't have Tom Boyd presently I would still fell confident in our list. He is not going to be the superman who saves us. He's only there to play one role, an important one but not irreplaceable.

I've come around a bit on Redpath but let's say I'm far from a believer and I don't think he has the size you need in a backup ruckman. Collins is 3 days from being drafted. Maybe we should let him do a couple of training sessions before we pencil him in. Stringer and Boyd aren't playing the same role. Both would benefit from the other. Boyd is the wagon we've hitched our long term key forward plans to and he needs to be that guy. We can be successful without him but if he can be the guy we paid for then we can be great.
If he can't overtake Redpath then it'll be a pretty poor result

[Bulldog4life]

Re: List Management 2015

He also kept bringing up Kobys name. I feel he's a coaches favourite or that was my take listening to Bevo,

Were you in the 5.30pm group or 6.30pm listening to Bevo BT?