25 Greatest Bulldogs

[jazzadogs]

Bernie played more games for Fitzroy. Of the others, who would they replace?

I think they got it right

From the players I predicted before any announcements, it's Blackburn and Donald in for Henderson and Bissett.

I think the 90s-present players were pretty clear.

This was from an AFL article the other day:
"Western Bulldogs CEO Ameet Bains was on the selection panel that included former senior coach Rodney Eade, legendary journalist Mike Sheahan, club historian Darren Arthur, board member Lisa Fitzpatrick and former Footscray player Ross Abbey.
The list is unranked, except for the top five, with the selection criteria encompassing how the player represented the club both on and off field.

Accolades are clearly important, but not everything, with the panel focusing on the figures who embody the Bulldogs spirit and have made the most considerable positive impact to the success of a club that celebrates 100 years in the VFL/AFL in 2025."

[jazzadogs]

25 Greatest Bulldogs (full list)

1925-45: Norm Ware, Harry Hickey, Arthur Olliver, Charlie Sutton, Allan Hopkins, Alby Morrison
1946-65: John Schultz, EJ Whitten, Wally Donald, Jack Collins
1966-85: Gary Dempsey, Doug Hawkins, Kelvin Templeton, Simon Beasley
1986-99: Scott Wynd, Chris Grant, Scott West, Brad Johnson, Tony Liberatore
2000-25: Bob Murphy, Matthew Boyd, Dale Morris, Tom Liberatore, Marcus Bontempelli, Ellie Blackburn

Now we have the final list of 25, whats your prediction for the top 5 in order?

My guess:
1 Whitten
2 Grant
3 Bont (I don't think they'll make him #2 because it puts a lot of pressure on him, but they might do it...)
4 Hawkins
5 Schultz

[Bornadog]

Now we have the final list of 25, whats your prediction for the top 5 in order?

My guess:
1 Whitten
2 Grant
3 Bont (I don't think they'll make him #2 because it puts a lot of pressure on him, but they might do it...)
4 Hawkins
5 Schultz

I think we are aligned - mine in no order

image.png

[Bornadog]

You can pick your 5 here: https://tb.westernbulldogs.com.au/tb_app/528170

[angelopetraglia]

With the risk of recency bias.

My top 5.

1. Bont
2. Whitten
3. Grant
4. Schultz
5. Johnson

Apologies to West and Hawkins

[Jeanette54]

1. Whitten
2. Hopkins
3. Bont
4. Hawkins
5. Sutton

Apologies: John Schultz, Chris Grant

[jeemak]

I don't see how Tom Liberatore makes the cut over Jack Macrae, on character grounds let alone on field performance. People forget how damaging he and his pinger rat set at the club were for our culture and performance post the grand final win. And at times before it. Not that I'm against pinger rats, I'm not a hypocrite, but I'm not being nominated for best 25 in the history of a footy club.

Jack was a solid citizen and absolutely elite from the word go, and was instrumental in a lot of important games at the club.

Brian Lake is the second best defender I've seen play for the club behind Chris Grant, but I think a lot of it is PR in terms of his omission. Easton Wood missing as a step-in premiership captain is pretty harsh, especially given his all Australian credentials and overall handsomeness.

[jazzadogs]

I don't see how Tom Liberatore makes the cut over Jack Macrae, on character grounds let alone on field performance. People forget how damaging he and his pinger rat set at the club were for our culture and performance post the grand final win. And at times before it. Not that I'm against pinger rats, I'm not a hypocrite, but I'm not being nominated for best 25 in the history of a footy club.

Jack was a solid citizen and absolutely elite from the word go, and was instrumental in a lot of important games at the club.

Brian Lake is the second best defender I've seen play for the club behind Chris Grant, but I think a lot of it is PR in terms of his omission. Easton Wood missing as a step-in premiership captain is pretty harsh, especially given his all Australian credentials and overall handsomeness.

His name has definitely played a part. As well as his outstanding career

In reality it's splitting hairs and I'm really comfortable Libba is in. We've had 16 men play 249+ games - Macrae, Steve Wallis, Gia and Rohan Smith the four that don't make the best 25.

[jeemak]

His name has definitely played a part. As well as his outstanding career

In reality it's splitting hairs and I'm really comfortable Libba is in. We've had 16 men play 249+ games - Macrae, Steve Wallis, Gia and Rohan Smith the four that don't make the best 25.

He's had a fantastic career, I'd never take that away from him.

I guess I've always been biased towards Jacko so maybe that's clouding my judgement. But what I've pointed out about what happened post the GF win still stands even if I'm not going to pull my skirt above my head over it.