Tweet
Pleased to see that Shaggy has made it at 50 in Mike Sheahan's Top 50 for '09 whilst Boydy at 15 now cements himself in the elite group. Other notables for the Dogs are Bryza at 18 and Crossy at 48.
-
-
Re: Sheahan's Top 50
Can someone throw the list up please not coming up with Google search and I'm interstate.But then again, I'm an Internet poster and Bevo is a premiership coach so draw your own conclusions. -
[COLOR="Red"][B][U][COLOR="Blue"]85, 92, 97, 98, 08, 09, 10... Break the curse![/COLOR][/U][/B][/COLOR]Comment
-
Re: Sheahan's Top 50
No list as such yet but you can view 50 to 11 from the attached URL
Comment
-
Re: Sheahan's Top 50
It's a tough job but I think he's got a good handle on it.
Nice to see Lake and Hargrave get some good recognition.Western Bulldogs Football Club "Where it's cool to drool"Comment
-
-
Re: Sheahan's Top 50
As someone who doesn't pay much attention to opposition teams, what sort of player is Nick Maxwell? He's at 38. And is Mitch Clark THAT good? (24)[B][COLOR="#0000CD"]Our club was born in blood and boots, not in AFL focus groups.[/COLOR][/B]Comment
-
Re: Sheahan's Top 50
Here is Mike Sheehan's top 50:
1. Gary Ablett - Geel
2. Nick Riewoldt - StK
3. Matthew Scarlett - Geel
4. Lenny Hayes - StK
5. Chris Judd - Carl
6. Joel Selwood - Geel
7. Jonathan Brown - Bris
8. Corey Enright - Geel
9. Nick Dal Santo - StK
10. Brendan Fevola - Carl
11. Jimmy Bartel - Geel
12. Dane Swan - Coll
13. Paul Chapman - Geel
14. Leigh Montagna - StK
15. Matthew Boyd - WB
16. Brendon Goddard - StK
17. Ryan O'Keefe - Syd
18. Brian Lake - WB
19. Marc Murphy - Carl
20. Scott Pendlebury - Coll
21. Sam Mitchell - Haw
22. Simon Black - Bris
23. Joel Corey - Geel
24. Mitch Clark - Bris
25. Simon Goodwin - Adel
26. Luke Power - Bris
27. Bernie Vince - Adel
28. Craig Bolton - Syd
29. Aaron Sandilands - Freo
30. Andrew Mackie - Geel
31. Cyril Rioli - Haw
32. Heath Shaw - Coll
33. Adam Goodes - Syd
34. Sam Fisher - StK
35. Mark LeCras - WCE
36. Jobe Watson - Ess
37. Darren Glass - WCE
38. Nick Maxwell - Coll
39. Darren Jolly - Syd
40. Cameron Ling - Geel
41. Alan Didak - Coll
42. Brad Sewell - Haw
43. Bryce Gibbs - Carl
44. Jason Porplyzia - Adel
45. Leon Davis - Coll
46. Dustin Fletcher - Ess
47. Lance Franklin - Haw
48. Daniel Cross - WB
49. Clinton Jones - StK
50. Ryan Hargrave - WB
The break up is:
9 - Geelong
7 - St.Kilda
6 - Collingwood
4 - Carlton
4 - Western Bulldogs
4 - Sydney
4 - Brisbane
4 - Hawthorn
3 - Adelaide
2 - Essendon
2 - West Coast
1 - Fremantle
0 - North Melbourne
0 - Melbourne
0 - Port Adelaide
0 - Richmond[COLOR="Red"][B][U][COLOR="Blue"]85, 92, 97, 98, 08, 09, 10... Break the curse![/COLOR][/U][/B][/COLOR]Comment
-
Re: Sheahan's Top 50
Scarlett + Judd too high in those top few IMO.
Judd is always guaranteed a Top 5 spot but he hasn't been near his best since 2006. Still a very gifted player, but he's not Top 5.
I'd have a number of players before Scarlett, too. He's a great player and very good again this season, but I don't think he was that good.
Still - a fairly good effort by Mike. It's not easy. Well done to Boyd too - climbing the ladder year by year.W00F!Comment
-
Re: Sheahan's Top 50
Agree..Scarlett too high..
Thought Swan, Chappy & Lecras would have been a bit higher otherwise I think its good..
Id like to think Harbrow would be there if it was a Top 60..
Lake & Boydy top 20 =
Comment
-
Re: Sheahan's Top 50
49. Clinton Jones - StK
oh please...Listening to Brahm's 3rd RacketComment
-
Re: Sheahan's Top 50
Isnt this over the past year not to do with previous seasons, or is it his top 50 playing now and takes in previous years?Bring back the biffComment
-
Re: Sheahan's Top 50
Can't see how on this season Scarlett can be #3 and Brian Lake can be #18?
You can mount an argument that Scarlett had a better season, but not by that type of gap.
Lake is the better mark, in particular from opposition kicks. Scarlett is a better re-bounder. Lake closed the gap this year.Comment
Comment