Bring Me Fantasia's Head.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Bring Me Fantasia's Head.

He was on the coaching commitee panel that appointed the bloke you want sacked!
More Chops gold

? I think I mentioned that already.
Again do you think Chris Grant has never made a mistake?

[Hotdog60]

Re: Bring Me Fantasia's Head.

Chris Grant has about 1000 awesomeness points to use before he can be sacked.

The man walks on water, you will have to hire Judas to fix him up.

[whythelongface]

Re: Bring Me Fantasia's Head.

?
Again do you think Chris Grant has never made a mistake?

Not that I am aware of.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Bring Me Fantasia's Head.

Who is defending Fantasia? Once he is out of contract I think he will have to weave some magic to get another one. The only thing that saved Monty last year was his contract.

Do you want me to write the posters names and/or just re-quote the posts?

[Ghost Dog]

Re: Bring Me Fantasia's Head.

Who is defending Fantasia? Once he is out of contract I think he will have to weave some magic to get another one. The only thing that saved Monty last year was his contract.

When is he out of contract? I'll put little sparkly stickers on my calendar.

[Maddog37]

Re: Bring Me Fantasia's Head.

Do you want me to write the posters names and/or just re-quote the posts?

Both please.

[stefoid]

Re: Bring Me Fantasia's Head.

Or... they're wrong?

Someone is wrong, that much is certain.

[Mofra]

Re: Bring Me Fantasia's Head.

Someone is wrong, that much is certain.

Possibly... or it is perhaps too early to tell?

I don't think it is worth sacking a coach after 12 months in the job,especially if he has some form of longer term plan to shape the playing style and playing list.

As for people who have been in their job much longer - it's far easier to make a reasonable judgement as to their performance. Whether good or bad, Fantasia certainly does need to have questions asked of him.

[stefoid]

Re: Bring Me Fantasia's Head.

The people calling for the coach to be sacked could be wrong...

[Dancin' Douggy]

Re: Bring Me Fantasia's Head.

If that's the case you can say Clayton brought us to 3 prelims as well.
In 3 Dalrymple drafts how many hits and misses has he had?

I'm pretty sure the core of the playing group that took us to 3 prelims were already there.
Clayton had way more misses than hits and in my opinion is hugely over rated.

[G-Mo77]

Re: Bring Me Fantasia's Head.

The people calling for the coach to be sacked could be wrong...

No they're right, they're always right just ask them.

[Sedat]

Re: Bring Me Fantasia's Head.

Clayton had way more misses than hits and in my opinion is hugely over rated.

At recruiting yes, at player contract negotiations there's probably nobody better in the AFL.

[Sedat]

Re: Bring Me Fantasia's Head.

Should Chris Grant be sacked?

Fantasia is Head of Football Operations, if he is so obviously failing in his duties surely his superior is failing in his responsibility to oversee him.

One minute you post about the dangers of CEO's being culpable for the errors of their staff, then next minute you suggest Fantasia's boss should be sacked because of Fantasia's errors? Which is is 'stache?

My position on Fantasia is clear. He has been in the role for a number of years and has under-performed dismally IMO. As such I would like to see a much better candidate lured to the club to replace him.

[GVGjr]

Re: Bring Me Fantasia's Head.

Do you want me to write the posters names and/or just re-quote the posts?

I can see little to no support for him at all. Just one or two people challenging the notion that sacking him will fix problems which I think is a fair response.

When things were going pear shaped for Eade last year there was only a couple of people really challenging Fantasia's record but now it's become a real focus by all and sundry.

I don't think Fantasia has performed well but there might be some internal reasons why he hasn't be able to. Hopefully the club can look a bit deeper and make the right call when they have to.

[GVGjr]

Re: Bring Me Fantasia's Head.

At recruiting yes, at player contract negotiations there's probably nobody better in the AFL.

Do we really have the intel to say this with a lot of conviction?
How do we know he does a better job in that area than Stephen Wells and others?