Josh Hill

[Ozza]

Re: Josh Hill

I would like to see some serious time put into Hill as a winger. Especially with Eagleton (presumably) gone at season's end. Watching some of Johnno's 300th - although its just one game - its clear Hill has the attributes. Whether he has the mindset is another story - but he is far more suited to a wing.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Josh Hill

Probably wont be there next year. will be traded or want a trade imo

[Sockeye Salmon]

Re: Josh Hill

Probably wont be there next year. will be traded or want a trade imo

I am staggered at the amount of love Hill gets. He has some skill, certainly but 1 decent mark and two goals out the back a game is simply not enough.

I absolutely hate trading but I would let Josh know that opportunities will be limited and he should get his manager to check out if other teams can offer him a regular game.

[The Bulldogs Bite]

Re: Josh Hill

I am staggered at the amount of love Hill gets. He has some skill, certainly but 1 decent mark and two goals out the back a game is simply not enough.

I absolutely hate trading but I would let Josh know that opportunities will be limited and he should get his manager to check out if other teams can offer him a regular game.

This season, yes.

But you've never rated him SS.

We've got far worse players than Hill.

[Sockeye Salmon]

Re: Josh Hill

This season, yes.

But you've never rated him SS.

We've got far worse players than Hill.

True, I haven't.

Early on I made the call that Josh was the new Pat Bowden. I stand by it.

[Rocco Jones]

Re: Josh Hill

I am staggered at the amount of love Hill gets. He has some skill, certainly but 1 decent mark and two goals out the back a game is simply not enough.

I know you're having a go at him (a fair one too) but the picture you are painting still beats our 22nd best player at the moment.

[Sockeye Salmon]

Re: Josh Hill

I know you're having a go at him (a fair one too) but the picture you are painting still beats our 22nd best player at the moment.

I would still have Hill behind Moles and Jones

[LostDoggy]

Re: Josh Hill

I would still have Hill behind Moles and Jones

Have you forgot the Stkilda game a year or two back? He has it just forgets how to use it.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Josh Hill

They don't read WOOF

I know of at least 2 who have a peek now and then.

[Sockeye Salmon]

Re: Josh Hill

Have you forgot the Stkilda game a year or two back? He has it just forgets how to use it.

Have you forgotten Patty's 4 goals against Melbourne?

Or Patrick Wiggins 3 against Melbourne in 2003?


How long can Hill live on Nick Del Santo simply ignoring him completely?

[LostDoggy]

Re: Josh Hill

Can we turn this guy around. Was best 22 last year. I heard he went home in the off season came back fat and with a poor attitude. Can we turn him back into a focussed player or should he be traded to WC for a first round pick?

[LostDoggy]

Re: Josh Hill

Can we turn this guy around. Was best 22 last year. I heard he went home in the off season came back fat and with a poor attitude. Can we turn him back into a focussed player or should he be traded to WC for a first round pick?

I doubt he'd be worth a first rounder.

[DOG GOD]

Re: Josh Hill

If we can get a 1st round pick i would take that, UNLESS the MC play him on the wing and let him run and carry the ball like he did in his debut year. If they do that then keep him.

If they want to keep persisiting with him as a permanent marking fwd, then WC it is.

[GVGjr]

Re: Josh Hill

Can we turn this guy around. Was best 22 last year. I heard he went home in the off season came back fat and with a poor attitude. Can we turn him back into a focussed player or should he be traded to WC for a first round pick?

I think Eade has flagged that guys without the right intensity will struggle to get a regular game and despite his talents, Hill would need to improve a lot in this area.

I'd rather keep him but not as a depth player. Would need a good offer to let him go.

[Sockeye Salmon]

Re: Josh Hill

If we can get a 1st round pick i would take that, UNLESS the MC play him on the wing and let him run and carry the ball like he did in his debut year. If they do that then keep him.

If they want to keep persisiting with him as a permanent marking fwd, then WC it is.

There would be no "unless" about anything.

If we got a first rounder for Hill it would mean we had pictures of someone doing a Fev to a goat. Not going to happen.