Booing Adam Goodes.

[Eastdog]

Re: Booing Adam Goodes.

Finey. Or however you're meant to spell it. On SEN has just revealed himself as a man I will never listen to, or respect again. Put a microphone in front if him and he becomes EMPOROR FINEY.

Don't really listen to SEN nowadays as much and especially don't listen to that Mark Fine show anymore as there are other ways too get news on the footy and we have forums like WOOF to discuss our club and other footy issues. Is it the same old callers ringing week after week?

[Happy Days]

Re: Booing Adam Goodes.

Finey. Or however you're meant to spell it. On SEN has just revealed himself as a man I will never listen to, or respect again. Put a microphone in front if him and he becomes EMPOROR FINEY.

What'd he say?

[Dancin' Douggy]

Re: Booing Adam Goodes.

What'd he say?

In a nutshell. Supporting the booers. Non stop, For his entire show.

[azabob]

Re: Booing Adam Goodes.

Finey. Or however you're meant to spell it. On SEN has just revealed himself as a man I will never listen to, or respect again. Put a microphone in front if him and he becomes EMPOROR FINEY.

What did he do?

[Eastdog]

Re: Booing Adam Goodes.

In a nutshell. Supporting the booers. Non stop, For his entire show.

Yes he has got his views which is fine but from memory from when I listened to him when a caller called in with view that differs to his views then he tries to shut them down. He has cut people off quite a few times.

[Remi Moses]

Re: Booing Adam Goodes.

But if fans think he's a knob, are they allowed to say that, or are they immediately racists.

The people of Australia did not vote for him to be Australian of the year. Talk to a lot of fans. I have a bunch of friends in sunshine, all immigrant Maltese, Italian etc. They can't stand him.

So do people hate Steve Waugh ? He was voted " Australian of the year"?
I think like Waugh, Goodes has done some decent things off field .
I think the issues been blurred somewhat, as it's a SECTION of footy fans booing him racially, and personally I don't want to boo with the section that are bigoted .

[Murphy'sLore]

Re: Booing Adam Goodes.

I think Finey is part of the 'you're not the boss of me' faction, and has trouble grasping the broader issues.

[The Doctor]

Re: Booing Adam Goodes.

From Brett Goodes Twitter


Brett Goodes @goodes23 Aug 2
So proud of my club, teammates & @BobMurphy02 in particular for the respect & support shown for Adam & our family this week! #IStandWithAdam
183 retweets 543 favorites
Reply Retweet183 Favorite543
More

[Ghost Dog]

Re: Booing Adam Goodes.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cultural_appropriation

It's entirely at Adam's discretion how he would like to perform the dance. A lot of this comes down to respecting the autonomy of the minority culture. It's not up to you to determine or judge the significance of the dance, or how Goodes feels about Australia Day, or how offensive the booing directed at him is. Just listen.

Well not in the court of public opinion. What you say is true, but not right. When Adam does his dance in front of a bunch of Collingwood supporters after kicking the winning goal, I'm sure we can just cite the Wikipedia article to them and I'm sure it will smooth everything over. it's a passionate sport! It's incitement, pure and simple, to opposition fans. The fact is there are indigenous writers who are uncomfortable with his cultural appropriation as people have cited in the thread. As Gvg says, that doesn't permit the knuckle-headed booing of him, Mexican wave like crowd sourced entertainment, for every possession he gets.

[Ghost Dog]

Re: Booing Adam Goodes.

So do people hate Steve Waugh ? He was voted " Australian of the year"?
I think like Waugh, Goodes has done some decent things off field .
I think the issues been blurred somewhat, as it's a SECTION of footy fans booing him racially, and personally I I don't want to boo with the section that are bigoted .

Can't remember Waugh saying Australia was based on lies, which taken as a sound bite, without listening to the whole speech, might cause friction. But considering the exploitation of aboriginal labor, rape, forced family separation, exploitation of resources etc, I totally understand Adam's point of view. And we do need people to bring these issues up, so good on him. He might want to remember that how you say things is important too. Listening to ABC radio national, there are a real diversity of opinions.

[GVGjr]

Re: Booing Adam Goodes.

From Brett Goodes Twitter


Brett Goodes @goodes23 Aug 2
So proud of my club, teammates & @BobMurphy02 in particular for the respect & support shown for Adam & our family this week! #IStandWithAdam
183 retweets 543 favorites
Reply Retweet183 Favorite5435
More

Read that Sunday night. Genuine thanks for the support his brother received.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Booing Adam Goodes.

Can't remember Waugh saying Australia was based on lies, which taken as a sound bite, without listening to the whole speech, might cause friction. But considering the exploitation of aboriginal labor, rape, forced family separation, exploitation of resources etc, I totally understand Adam's point of view. And we do need people to bring these issues up, so good on him. He might want to remember that how you say things is important too. Listening to ABC radio national, there are a real diversity of opinions.

If he'd made the speech at any other ceremony or function, it would not have reached its intended audience.

When you stand up for something, you don't ask the people you're standing up to for permission. You don't ask them what time would be more convenient for them.

Same goes for the war dance. I've heard twits on the radio compare it to the haka, and claim he should have directed it at the opposition like the Kiwis do. Well, the opposition players weren't booing him. In fact, they've mostly come out in support.

Did he need to ask for approval to stand up to the crowd? NO.

The 13 year old. It's not his fault she said what she said. Maybe he could have handled it differently if she'd blurted it out at a different place and time, but that's not what happened. Did he need to ask permission to take offence? NO.

Is Adam Goodes sometimes inciteful? Even divisive? You betcha. And rightly so! Those freedoms were hard fought.

[Dancin' Douggy]

Re: Booing Adam Goodes.

I do feel sorry for all the people out there that are scared of invisible spears.

[Bornadog]

Re: Booing Adam Goodes.

I do feel sorry for all the people out there that are scared of invisible spears.

Apparently it was a boomerang

[Twodogs]

Re: Booing Adam Goodes.

Apparently it was a boomerang

Even worse. You could take several people fake out with one of those.