Welcome to the Bulldogs: Bailey Smith

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • GVGjr
    Moderator
    • Nov 2006
    • 44085

    Re: Welcome to the Bulldogs: Bailey Smith

    Originally posted by jazzadogs
    I think we need to stop referring to this year's pick as a first - it will be 20, which realistically is a second round pick. And every chance that next year is the same (if they even offer another 'first').

    Pretty much the best deal we can hope for is 2x pick 20 odd (assuming Cats continue as usual and make a prelim).
    We all know where Geelong's picks this year are situated and future picks are always a lottery. The point is it's already at a discount so I don't understand why so many think we should accept inferior offers because apparently something is better than nothing.

    It's an unlikely scenario to put a player into the PSD and if our supporters are okay with a couple of picks for next year then we won't need to but just accepting whatever they offer isn't okay with me.
    Western Bulldogs Football Club "Where it's cool to drool"

    Comment

    • The Pie Man
      Coaching Staff
      • May 2008
      • 3498

      Re: Welcome to the Bulldogs: Bailey Smith

      Originally posted by Rocco Jones
      Because they'd be signing a player who doesn't want to be there on an inflated short term contract. There's also the Mental Health aspect, whether it's real or just playing a card. He will nominate a deal that's basically fake and then re-negotiate deal with Geelong. It's bullshit but we know the AFL won't do anything about it. We also know the AFL media narrative will be about us being belligerent rather than it being tantamount to draft tampering.
      They can back themselves in to convince him that Punt Rd is the way - he’d suit their rebuild and the douche will get big crowds and the perfect market for whatever canned sh$t he sells.

      Richmond would almost be a win win if we harbor any real ambition to challenge the next 2 years.
      Float Along - Fill Your Lungs

      Comment

      • Rocco Jones
        Bulldog Team of the Century
        • Jun 2008
        • 6923

        Re: Welcome to the Bulldogs: Bailey Smith

        Originally posted by The Pie Man
        They can back themselves in to convince him that Punt Rd is the way - he’d suit their rebuild and the douche will get big crowds and the perfect market for whatever canned sh$t he sells.

        Richmond would almost be a win win if we harbor any real ambition to challenge the next 2 years.
        And lose that Cotton On deal that’s technically not linked to Geelong but we know it 100% is? It’s draft/trade/player tampering but we know AFL will look the other way.

        Comment

        • Grantysghost
          Bouncing Strong
          • Apr 2010
          • 18820

          Re: Welcome to the Bulldogs: Bailey Smith

          Originally posted by GVGjr
          We all know where Geelong's picks this year are situated and future picks are always a lottery. The point is it's already at a discount so I don't understand why so many think we should accept inferior offers because apparently something is better than nothing.

          It's an unlikely scenario to put a player into the PSD and if our supporters are okay with a couple of picks for next year then we won't need to but just accepting whatever they offer isn't okay with me.
          Always add a buffer year to a contract and never let them run out for a young player like Baz.
          BT COME BACK!​

          Comment

          • jazzadogs
            Bulldog Team of the Century
            • Oct 2008
            • 5535

            Re: Welcome to the Bulldogs: Bailey Smith

            Originally posted by GVGjr
            We all know where Geelong's picks this year are situated and future picks are always a lottery. The point is it's already at a discount so I don't understand why so many think we should accept inferior offers because apparently something is better than nothing.

            It's an unlikely scenario to put a player into the PSD and if our supporters are okay with a couple of picks for next year then we won't need to but just accepting whatever they offer isn't okay with me.
            I'm with you on the structure of what is acceptable. I just think saying 'two first round picks' is so misleading because it's actually pick 20 and likely pick 15+. The first round these days stretches to 25 picks half the time.

            Two top 20 picks is my preference.
            If the offer was pick 20 this year and their future second I wouldn't accept.

            Comment

            • Uninformed
              Draftee
              • Jan 2023
              • 759

              Re: Welcome to the Bulldogs: Bailey Smith

              Like the Judd deal with Pratt for Carltom, Smiths Cotton-on link with Geelong looks really suss. It could all be above board, but perceptions matter.

              For the sake of being perceived to do the right thing the AFL should deny the Bailey Smith trade to Geelong. Any other team, no problems. But the Geelong move looks bad for the integrity of the competition and should be a no go.

              Comment

              • ledge
                Hall of Fame
                • Dec 2007
                • 14068

                Re: Welcome to the Bulldogs: Bailey Smith

                Originally posted by Uninformed
                Like the Judd deal with Pratt for Carltom, Smiths Cotton-on link with Geelong looks really suss. It could all be above board, but perceptions matter.

                For the sake of being perceived to do the right thing the AFL should deny the Bailey Smith trade to Geelong. Any other team, no problems. But the Geelong move looks bad for the integrity of the competition and should be a no go.
                Problem is if you have no facts of wrong doing you can’t penalise a team just because you think it’s suspicious
                .
                Bring back the biff

                Comment

                • Bornadog
                  WOOF Clubhouse Leader
                  • Jan 2007
                  • 65832

                  Re: Welcome to the Bulldogs: Bailey Smith

                  Originally posted by jazzadogs
                  I'm with you on the structure of what is acceptable. I just think saying 'two first round picks' is so misleading because it's actually pick 20 and likely pick 15+. The first round these days stretches to 25 picks half the time.

                  Two top 20 picks is my preference.
                  If the offer was pick 20 this year and their future second I wouldn't accept.
                  It's still pick 15 (sort of) because the same 15 are available to all clubs. The others pushing it to 20 are ungettable anyway.
                  FFC: Established 1883

                  Premierships: AFL 1954, 2016 VFA - 1898,99,1900, 1908, 1913, 1919-20, 1923-24, VFL: 2014, 2016 . Champions of Victoria 1924. AFLW - 2018.

                  Comment

                  • jeemak
                    Bulldog Legend
                    • Oct 2010
                    • 21507

                    Re: Welcome to the Bulldogs: Bailey Smith

                    Originally posted by bornadog
                    It's still pick 15 (sort of) because the same 15 are available to all clubs. The others pushing it to 20 are ungettable anyway.
                    It's a decent point. In times past such players would have been taken with third rounders.
                    TF is this?.........Obviously you're not a golfer.

                    Comment

                    • Bornadog
                      WOOF Clubhouse Leader
                      • Jan 2007
                      • 65832

                      Re: Welcome to the Bulldogs: Bailey Smith

                      Originally posted by jeemak
                      It's a decent point. In times past such players would have been taken with third rounders.
                      Father/sons, Academy push it out but we couldn't pick them anyhow
                      FFC: Established 1883

                      Premierships: AFL 1954, 2016 VFA - 1898,99,1900, 1908, 1913, 1919-20, 1923-24, VFL: 2014, 2016 . Champions of Victoria 1924. AFLW - 2018.

                      Comment

                      • jeemak
                        Bulldog Legend
                        • Oct 2010
                        • 21507

                        Re: Welcome to the Bulldogs: Bailey Smith

                        Originally posted by bornadog
                        Father/sons, Academy push it out but we couldn't pick them anyhow
                        Yes, I understood the first time!
                        TF is this?.........Obviously you're not a golfer.

                        Comment

                        • Rocco Jones
                          Bulldog Team of the Century
                          • Jun 2008
                          • 6923

                          Re: Welcome to the Bulldogs: Bailey Smith

                          As a bit of the guide, decent players drafted at 19/20/21 in recent years:

                          2017- W Powell, O Allen
                          2018- Stocker
                          2019- SDK, T Dow
                          2020- F Macrae, Holmes, Bowey
                          2021- JVR, Lohmann, M Johnson
                          2022- E Allan, Konstantly, D Jones

                          Comment

                          • jazzadogs
                            Bulldog Team of the Century
                            • Oct 2008
                            • 5535

                            Re: Welcome to the Bulldogs: Bailey Smith

                            Originally posted by bornadog
                            It's still pick 15 (sort of) because the same 15 are available to all clubs. The others pushing it to 20 are ungettable anyway.
                            So you're saying that we did pay too much for Sanders...

                            I can see your point and hadn't really thought about it like that.

                            Comment

                            • GVGjr
                              Moderator
                              • Nov 2006
                              • 44085

                              Re: Welcome to the Bulldogs: Bailey Smith

                              Originally posted by Rocco Jones
                              Because they'd be signing a player who doesn't want to be there on an inflated short term contract. There's also the Mental Health aspect, whether it's real or just playing a card. He will nominate a deal that's basically fake and then re-negotiate deal with Geelong. It's bullshit but we know the AFL won't do anything about it. We also know the AFL media narrative will be about us being belligerent rather than it being tantamount to draft tampering.
                              I don't believe players can nominate fake deals to get through the drafts because the clubs needs to be able to meet that.
                              Heavily front loaded contracts are also an issue.
                              We can search for reasons not to stand our ground but we will prove PETA right and fast track the Mutt moniker if we just roll over and submit to the softer touch and some cheap treats.

                              I don't care if we cop a bad wrap in the media and we should be prepared to ride out a difficult trade period
                              Western Bulldogs Football Club "Where it's cool to drool"

                              Comment

                              • Grantysghost
                                Bouncing Strong
                                • Apr 2010
                                • 18820

                                Re: Welcome to the Bulldogs: Bailey Smith

                                Originally posted by jazzadogs
                                So you're saying that we did pay too much for Sanders...

                                I can see your point and hadn't really thought about it like that.
                                However they are the 20th (say pushed back 5) best talent probably so it's not 15.
                                BT COME BACK!​

                                Comment

                                Working...