Who gets delisted?

[Missing Dog]

Re: Who gets delisted?

It is not where we start cutting that is the problem...it is how do you stop?

For me, there is really not much point in continuing with Addison, Moles, Skinner, Hooper, Mulligan or Prato...or, being really harsh - Gilbee.

I think Stack will survive, I think Moles will survive and I think (because he is contracted) that Hooper survives.

Stack told my nephew he didn't want to stay

[Mofra]

Re: Who gets delisted?

We have the new Libba - his name is Libba

[stefoid]

Re: Who gets delisted?

Stack told my nephew he didn't want to stay

Well that simplifies things greatly

[Bulldog4life]

Re: Who gets delisted?

Excluding the players traded out and retired

Main list- Addison, Stack

Rookies- Prato, Hahn

Promote Dahlhaus and Panos.

That leaves 5 draft selections and 4 rookie selections.

Mulligan and Hooper need to go, but I'd cut deeper next year in an umcompromised draft and use our compensation picks.

If true that Stack wants to go this is how I would go too. This gives us a good number (9) of new players to the list.

[Maddog37]

Re: Who gets delisted?

I think it is too early to tell with Skinner.

Hooper is only worth persisting with if he changes his body shape. Easier said than done though you would think by looking at him. There is alt of Gary Moorcroft about him.

[Maddog37]

Re: Who gets delisted?

Any chance we can delist James Fantasia because he doesnt appear to be capable of negotiating deals during trade week.

After listening to his interview on SEN, he wasnt able to achieve any of the dealings he said they were aiming for.

So he should of handed over first round pick for Bate to get the deal done?

[Remi Moses]

Re: Who gets delisted?

So he should of handed over first round pick for Bate to get the deal done?

Agree, it's amazing how datsun 180 B's become ferari's in trade week.
Couldn't get Crouch because we didn't have a pick High enough for him.
Wouldn't give a 1St rounder for a Fringe player
Caddy only wanted Essendon( lesson for GC, it's impossible to deal with them)
The rest are just canon fodder. We got picks for 2 players who would have been delisted

[G-Mo77]

Re: Who gets delisted?

Stack told my nephew he didn't want to stay

Beggars can't be choosers.

Bye bye Brennan.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Who gets delisted?

Caddy only wanted Essendon( lesson for GC, it's impossible to deal with them)
The rest are just canon fodder. We got picks for 2 players who would have been delisted

I found that one strange. I heard the manager speak like a politician trying to explain how Essendon was the only club Caddy prepared to deal with.
I find it hard to believe. Would like to hear from Clayton.
If he is as good as they say he could be, I would have offer our ward compo and 17(or a player).

[azabob]

Re: Who gets delisted?

I found that one strange. I heard the manager speak like a politician trying to explain how Essendon was the only club Caddy prepared to deal with.
I find it hard to believe. Would like to hear from Clayton.
If he is as good as they say he could be, I would have offer our ward compo and 17(or a player).

Chops, according to Emma Quayle and Marcus Ashcroft we did try and get Caddy.

This is from today's article.



Suns football manager Marcus Ashcroft yesterday expressed frustration that the club had been asked to deal solely with Essendon, as Melbourne and the Western Bulldogs made fruitless last-hour inquiries, however the Caddy camp believed the club had preferred this option all along because neither of them wanted to give the impression that he was available for auction.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/bombers-fail-to-snare-caddy-20111017-1ltds.html

[Hotdog60]

Re: Who gets delisted?

Chops, according to Emma Quayle and Marcus Ashcroft we did try and get Caddy.

This is from today's article.



Suns football manager Marcus Ashcroft yesterday expressed frustration that the club had been asked to deal solely with Essendon, as Melbourne and the Western Bulldogs made fruitless last-hour inquiries, however the Caddy camp believed the club had preferred this option all along because neither of them wanted to give the impression that he was available for auction.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-new...017-1ltds.html

So if it was just to get back to Melbourne because of he's father health wasn't all of the story, it was more of a case of wanting to play for the Bombers otherwise he would have entertained any Melbourne based club.

After reading that I wouldn't want him as I would query his commitment.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Who gets delisted?

According to Emma Quayle's article we will be making 4 selections plus rookie upgrades. So if we only upgrade Dahlhaus we won't need to delist anybody (Five spots currently available due to loss of Hill, Reid, Hudson, Hall and Ward). But if we upgrade more then one rookie we will need to delist someone.

[Sockeye Salmon]

Re: Who gets delisted?

According to Emma Quayle's article we will be making 4 selections plus rookie upgrades. So if we only upgrade Dahlhaus we won't need to delist anybody (Five spots currently available due to loss of Hill, Reid, Hudson, Hall and Ward). But if we upgrade more then one rookie we will need to delist someone.

Straight choice - Mulligan or Panos

Pretty easy decision

[Greystache]

Re: Who gets delisted?

According to Emma Quayle's article we will be making 4 selections plus rookie upgrades. So if we only upgrade Dahlhaus we won't need to delist anybody (Five spots currently available due to loss of Hill, Reid, Hudson, Hall and Ward). But if we upgrade more then one rookie we will need to delist someone.

I'd think we'd upgrade Panos too. To me that means Stack or Addison will go as well.

[Remi Moses]

Re: Who gets delisted?

I found that one strange. I heard the manager speak like a politician trying to explain how Essendon was the only club Caddy prepared to deal with.
I find it hard to believe. Would like to hear from Clayton.
If he is as good as they say he could be, I would have offer our ward compo and 17(or a player).

Not doubting the kids motives, but if he was keen to return to Melb why didn't he want to join anyone else? Hopefully they'll start falling out of the trees up there.
Little revenge for Harbrow would be nice.