Talking trades

[Bornadog]

Re: Talking trades

If Melbourne are prepared to give up Pick 13 for Dawes, they should fold.

As mentioned in another thread, Collingwood want pick 4 in exchange for Dawes and Wellingham

[jazzadogs]

Re: Talking trades

As mentioned in another thread, Collingwood want pick 4 in exchange for Dawes and Wellingham

Surely Melbourne wouldn't want Wellingham when he's already announced that he wants to go home? Surely he'll just go home again after this contract?

Doesn't make sense to me...

[The Bulldogs Bite]

Re: Talking trades

As mentioned in another thread, Collingwood want pick 4 in exchange for Dawes and Wellingham

Wellingham won't goto Melbourne.

There's suggestion 13 could be on the table for Dawes, especially if they aren't forced to use #3 on Viney.

[anfo27]

Re: Talking trades

This whole 900 thousand extra is total rubbish
If it comes under the "cost of living " then Adelaide and Brissie would have a smaller cap.
It should come under the "we always won't Sydney strong" banner.

Not sure how the cost of living in Sydney effects guys who earn a six figure salary. People who earn the national average sure but Kurt Tippett earning $800,000 ain't going to notice the cost of living one bit.

[azabob]

Re: Talking trades

Is he free agency?

If we were to pick him up and lose Minson, the AFL will call it all square and we wouldn't get any compo for Minson.

Speaking of compensation, can St.Kilda use there Goddard compensation this draft (2012) or does it have to be 2013? I have read conflicting sources, but now can't find either.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Talking trades

Wellingham won't goto Melbourne.

There's suggestion 13 could be on the table for Dawes, especially if they aren't forced to use #3 on Viney.

Last I heard Wellingham chose West Coast after not wanting to goto Melbourne...must of changed again?

Collingwood generally get the better end of the deal during trade week..but should not receive anything higher than Melbourne's Pick 26 for him. Even thats generous.

On the Tippett stakes, what can Sydney offer Adelaide, pick 22 aint gunna do it, maybe they should throw Everitt in as a sweetener?

[Remi Moses]

Re: Talking trades

Could The Crows do what port did with Nick Stevens?
Sticking it to a top 4 competitor and forcing him to GC?
Imagine on here if Fantasia drew up a contract that Tippet had!
Interesting times

[LongWait]

Re: Talking trades

Speaking of compensation, can St.Kilda use there Goddard compensation this draft (2012) or does it have to be 2013? I have read conflicting sources, but now can't find either.

Any free agency compensation must be used in the year it is granted. So the compensation pick for Goddard must be used or traded and then used this draft.

[azabob]

Re: Talking trades

Any free agency compensation must be used in the year it is granted. So the compensation pick for Goddard must be used or traded and then used this draft.

Thanks LongWait but as alluded to earlier it can be "watered down" if you in turn sign up a free agent.

[azabob]

Re: Talking trades

Wellingham won't goto Melbourne.

There's suggestion 13 could be on the table for Dawes, especially if they aren't forced to use #3 on Viney.

Last I heard Wellingham chose West Coast after not wanting to goto Melbourne...must of changed again?

Huh? You have said what bulldogs bit has said, so nothing has changed.

[Bulldog Joe]

Re: Talking trades

Last I heard Wellingham chose West Coast after not wanting to goto Melbourne...must of changed again?

Collingwood generally get the better end of the deal during trade week..but should not receive anything higher than Melbourne's Pick 26 for him. Even thats generous.

On the Tippett stakes, what can Sydney offer Adelaide, pick 22 aint gunna do it, maybe they should throw Everitt in as a sweetener?

Not sure how Everitt could be a sweetener. He is more in the category of lemon.

[KT31]

Re: Talking trades

Not sure how Everitt could be a sweetener. He is more in the category of lemon.

Pretty sure alexxx meant it in jest.

[DOG GOD]

Re: Talking trades

Just saw on my local news that the dogs have offered collingwood their 2nd round pick for Dawes.

I hope not.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Talking trades

Huh? You have said what bulldogs bit has said, so nothing has changed.

Woops, I quoted the wrong person, was meant to quote who he quoted

Pretty sure alexxx meant it in jest.

Correct.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Talking trades

Just saw on my local news that the dogs have offered collingwood their 2nd round pick for Dawes.

I hope not.

Which would be pick 27. Also hope not. We haven't got a very good 2nd-club-forward recruit track record.

Edit: sorry for double post