Stringer Trade Worth

[Mofra]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Surely Matthew Lloyd is joking in regards to the Bombers plan to get Jake for pick 19? I hope the Dogs stick to their word and don't accept anything below a top 10 pick (pick 11 at worst). I'd rather Jake suck it up in the VFL or clean toilets at the club than let Essendon dictate the terms. Didn't the Saints give the Bombers pick 5 or something for Carlisle? But a premiership player and AA is only worth pick 19?? They need to get their hand off it.

Carlisle was the equivalent of pick 14 on points - Saints got a bit back.

[The Bulldogs Bite]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Apparently Cooney said Francis is worth Pick 10.

I can't stand this flog - that he even has a job is baffling.

[ledge]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Apparently Cooney said Francis is worth Pick 10.

I can't stand this flog - that he even has a job is baffling.

That's awesome that means Jake is worth at least two number 1s , Essendon better end up last the next two years if they want him then.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Trade radio tweet saying talking Essendon begun. Kerr from Essendon saying pick 11 may need to be used to land Stringer. Confident that a deal will be reached now.

And SA clubs no real interest in Francis.

[bulldogsthru&thru]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Trade radio tweet saying talking Essendon begun. Kerr from Essendon saying pick 11 may need to be used to land Stringer. Confident that a deal will be reached now.

And SA clubs no real interest in Francis.

So long as we don't give anything back in return for just 11. I don't want to be sending them 26 back

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

So long as we don't give anything back in return for just 11. I don't want to be sending them 26 back

Yep, that's still a poor result being a 15 pick upgrade.

[Rocket Science]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Surely Matthew Lloyd is joking in regards to the Bombers plan to get Jake for pick 19?

Puts the hilarity in perspective when with the same breath he suggests Saad is worth pick 11 to facilitate his little fantasy.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Scratch that. Kerr talked about a Stringer trade over the course of 10 days.

This is the threat. Other deals get knocked around, and our attention distracted.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Puts the hilarity in perspective when with the same breath he suggests Saad is worth pick 11 to facilitate his little fantasy.

They've already put an offer to the Suns, as their first domino to fall. My guess 11 for Saad and 19. If Scott Clayton gives them that, then the best they can offer is pick 19 & a player or pick 19 & future pick for Stringer.

We will soon see if we are bluffing on Stringer or ice cold negotiators.

[Happy Days]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

If we give up 26 then I want Dal and McCartney gone. That would be so pathetic of us.

[ledge]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Trade radio tweet saying talking Essendon begun. Kerr from Essendon saying pick 11 may need to be used to land Stringer. Confident that a deal will be reached now.

And SA clubs no real interest in Francis.

So francis is worth pick 10 according to Coons but clubs aren't interested.. I think that says it all.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

So francis is worth pick 10 according to Coons but clubs aren't interested.. I think that says it all.

I usually start a thread each year 'dumbest trade rumours'. Probably easier to assume they're all from Cooney and save me the effort of starting a thread.

[mitch0418]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Carlisle was the equivalent of pick 14 on points - Saints got a bit back.

In the deal:
- Essendon receives Bird and pick No.5, gives up Carlisle and pick No.44, and exchanges pick No.23 for pick No.24;
- St Kilda receives Carlisle and pick No.14 and gives up pick No.5 and pick No.24;
- Sydney Swans receive picks No.23 and pick No.44, and gives up pick No.14 and Bird.

My point is that the Saints gave up pick 5 to Essendon for Carlisle. If Carlisle was worth pick 5 then Jake is worth just as much so we stick to our guns or he stays.

[Topdog]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

They've already put an offer to the Suns, as their first domino to fall. My guess 11 for Saad and 19. If Scott Clayton gives them that, then the best they can offer is pick 19 & a player or pick 19 & future pick for Stringer.

We will soon see if we are bluffing on Stringer or ice cold negotiators.

I just dont see why GC do that trade. It makes no sense at all.

[GVGjr]

Re: Stringer Trade Worth

Trade radio tweet saying talking Essendon begun. Kerr from Essendon saying pick 11 may need to be used to land Stringer. Confident that a deal will be reached now.

And SA clubs no real interest in Francis.

I heard it a bit different, he said pick 11 would be used in an effort to acquire the 3 players they are after. He said the deals would be independent of Francis