If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Seems a waste of time to bring in another mid that doesn't play a different role. Garcia and McLean, though not reliable to be fit, are more the type of players better suited to be that midfield depth since they can play other roles.
Surely our focus/salary would be better placed in different areas of the ground? Any of a lockdown small defender, crumbing pressure forward, specialist wingman and of course key defender would be more urgent areas of need IMO. And since there are 4 positions I could name without much thought (maybe I've even missed some) I think we can make do with just the 5 A-grade quality midfielders. Different instructions/mindset may be required but the quality is there.
Seems a waste of time to bring in another mid that doesn't play a different role. Garcia and McLean, though not reliable to be fit, are more the type of players better suited to be that midfield depth since they can play other roles.
Surely our focus/salary would be better placed in different areas of the ground? Any of a lockdown small defender, crumbing pressure forward, specialist wingman and of course key defender would be more urgent areas of need IMO. And since there are 4 positions I could name without much thought (maybe I've even missed some) I think we can make do with just the 5 A-grade quality midfielders. Different instructions/mindset may be required but the quality is there.
If Dunkley went out, Id be very tempted to go after Acres - not as a direct replacement but as someone who can plug and play that wing role effectively for us
There is no doubt Junior Rioli is a quality footballer but after having held a spot for him for 2 years from a most stupid ban he has put his hand up to leave the Eagles after just 12 months back.
Western Bulldogs Football Club "Where it's cool to drool"
There is no doubt Junior Rioli is a quality footballer but after having held a spot for him for 2 years from a most stupid ban he has put his hand up to leave the Eagles after just 12 months back.
He says he wants more money for his future.
FFC: Established 1883
Premierships: AFL 1954, 2016 VFA - 1898,99,1900, 1908, 1913, 1919-20, 1923-24, VFL: 2014, 2016 . Champions of Victoria 1924. AFLW - 2018.
Assuming Dunkley leaves then there is an opening, but I think we should use the opportunity to change the complexion, so I wouldn't be bringing in a Dunkley replacement as such.
I'd much rather we looked to get in a B grade mid that knows they are a B grade mid and can play a role in there for the team. That's why someone like Willem Drew, or maybe Will Setterfield appeals to me. I guess George Heweitt is another example.
Assuming Dunkley leaves then there is an opening, but I think we should use the opportunity to change the complexion, so I wouldn't be bringing in a Dunkley replacement as such.
I'd much rather we looked to get in a B grade mid that knows they are a B grade mid and can play a role in there for the team. That's why someone like Willem Drew, or maybe Will Setterfield appeals to me. I guess George Heweitt is another example.
Or increase mid rotations with Treloar, Baz and West and consider a wing and a small forward?
Comment