Other clubs delistings/Want out - 2014

[ledge]

Re: Other clubs delistings/Want out - 2014

Blease is a little like Tutt, quick runner but kicking and physicality is not to standard.

Melbourne are apparently sniffing around Tutty. How's Blease for Tutt?

If they are the same kind of player why would you bother swapping, Tutt has a lot of going for him, just a matter of time with him.

[lemmon]

Re: Other clubs delistings/Want out - 2014

Blease is a little like Tutt, quick runner but kicking and physicality is not to standard.

Melbourne are apparently sniffing around Tutty. How's Blease for Tutt?

Feels like a downgrade for mine. Tutty has at least shown gradual improvement and an ability around the big sticks Blease lacks.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Other clubs delistings/Want out - 2014

Feels like a downgrade for mine. Tutty has at least shown gradual improvement and an ability around the big sticks Blease lacks.

If we were Melbourne we'd say the same thing back, handful of games, soft-ish, goes missing (I'm not saying that, just guessing an outsiders view). That's why I think it's an outside chance. Both sides would be banking that the old club hasn't done enough with them. Tutty looks no closer to being a senior player than 12 months ago, wouldn't be the worse trade. My only concern is another player with kicking issues.

[Twodogs]

Re: Other clubs delistings/Want out - 2014

If we were Melbourne we'd say the same thing back, handful of games, soft-ish, goes missing (I'm not saying that, just guessing an outsiders view). That's why I think it's an outside chance. Both sides would be banking that the old club hasn't done enough with them. Tutty looks no closer to being a senior player than 12 months ago, wouldn't be the worse trade. My only concern is another player with kicking issues.

They would know Tutty almost as well as we do I reckon with the amount of forward scouting they do these days.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Other clubs delistings/Want out - 2014

They would know Tutty almost as well as we do I reckon with the amount of forward scouting they do these days.

If we both think we can turn the other player around, that's a win/win trade. Just not massive names.

[Bulldog4life]

Re: Other clubs delistings/Want out - 2014

If we were Melbourne we'd say the same thing back, handful of games, soft-ish, goes missing (I'm not saying that, just guessing an outsiders view). That's why I think it's an outside chance. Both sides would be banking that the old club hasn't done enough with them. Tutty looks no closer to being a senior player than 12 months ago, wouldn't be the worse trade. My only concern is another player with kicking issues.

Have to disagree with you BT. I thought Tutty improved again this year. His concussion cost him two weeks and he never got back in. I though he had been showing good signs up to that point.

[The Bulldogs Bite]

Re: Other clubs delistings/Want out - 2014

Blease is crap.

His decision making is absolutely woeful, and his disposal is almost as bad. He can run fast - but that's it.

Massive no.

[Twodogs]

Re: Other clubs delistings/Want out - 2014

If we both think we can turn the other player around, that's a win/win trade. Just not massive names.

I'd much rather keep Tutt. He's a superior player.

[Remi Moses]

Re: Other clubs delistings/Want out - 2014

Ditto here Tutt's a better player.

[Axe Man]

Re: Other clubs delistings/Want out - 2014

Giant wants out

RUCKMAN Jonathan Giles is seeking a trade from Greater Western Sydney after struggling for opportunities behind Shane Mumford in 2014.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Other clubs delistings/Want out - 2014

Giant wants out

Got to be asking the question, we are a ruckman short. Maybe two as I prefer to use a rookie spot as well on a developing type.

[BulldogBelle]

Re: Other clubs delistings/Want out - 2014

I'd pass. I'd prefer to chase the KPPs that are looking for a new home and return Roughy to the ruck.

[Dry Rot]

Re: Other clubs delistings/Want out - 2014

Got to be asking the question, we are a ruckman short. Maybe two as I prefer to use a rookie spot as well on a developing type.

Anyone got a view on the Hawk's Grimley? Worth looking at?

[Happy Days]

Re: Other clubs delistings/Want out - 2014

I think Giles is better than Minson.

[Remi Moses]

Re: Other clubs delistings/Want out - 2014

Anyone got a view on the Hawk's Grimley? Worth looking at?

He's played less than 10 games in 5 years,not a lot of body of work.
( even in a great team)